Date: 04 Apr 2001 05:51:03 +0200 From: Cyrille Lefevre <clefevre-lists@noos.fr> To: "David O'Brien" <arch@FreeBSD.ORG> Cc: Cy Schubert - ITSD Open Systems Group <Cy.Schubert@uumail.gov.bc.ca>, Jack Rusher <jar@integratus.com>, Neil Blakey-Milner <nbm@mithrandr.moria.org>, Michael Lucas <mwlucas@blackhelicopters.org>, "litos2001@libero.it" <litos2001@libero.it> Subject: Re: Startup scripts a la NetBSD Message-ID: <ofuds4pk.fsf@gits.dyndns.org> In-Reply-To: <20010330115252.A93566@dragon.nuxi.com> References: <3AC4B808.9EB5806B@integratus.com> <200103301810.f2UIAGK06787@cwsys.cwsent.com> <20010330115252.A93566@dragon.nuxi.com>
next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
--=-=-=
"David O'Brien" <arch@FreeBSD.ORG> writes:
> On Fri, Mar 30, 2001 at 10:09:39AM -0800, Cy Schubert - ITSD Open Systems Group wrote:
> > Becoming more SYSV-like is not something most people in FreeBSD are
> > enamoured with. Hence I don't think it would be possible to implement
> > all the changes I would like to see.
>
> Correct. Make that HELL NO WE WON'T GO SVR4!!!
>
> The BSD init + NetBSD granular rc files is a nice compromise. And thus
> why I am pushing a move in that direction.
some times ago, I've setup a NetBSD box and they init files are not yet
perfect. as I remember me, you couldn't do something like
/etc/rc.d/nfs.server start (or whatever) while nfs.server depends on
something else. you only could do /etc/rc which start all things.
also, I don't remember if they are checking if the service is already
started as HP-UX does.
in the same time (`ls -ld /etc/init.d` = Nov 23 :), I've began
something like in attachement which allow us to start/stop all
dependencies as I remember me. at least the nfs stack is working since
I use it when I need it. of course, this was an experiment and need to
be enhanced/reworked.
the basic idea was it have a generic wrapper which source its
configuration file a la HP-UX. the configuration file would be
something like this (from nfs.server) :
service_class=
service_instance=nfs_server
service_enable=YES
service_proc=nfsd
service_path=/sbin
service_program=$service_path/$service_proc
service_flags=
nfsd_pre_start () {
case ${nfs_reserved_port_only} in
[Yy][Ee][Ss])
echo -n ' NFS on reserved port only=YES'
sysctl -w vfs.nfs.nfs_privport=1 >/dev/null
;;
esac
}
nfsd_post_start () {
if [ -n "${nfs_bufpackets}" ]; then
sysctl -w vfs.nfs.bufpackets=${nfs_bufpackets} >/dev/null
fi
}
service_pre_start=nfsd_pre_start
service_pre_start_depend="portmap mountd"
service_post_start=nfsd_post_start
service_post_start_depend="lockd statd"
service_pre_stop=
service_pre_stop_depend=$service_post_start_depend
service_force_stop=true
service_post_stop=
service_post_stop_depend=mountd
and the wrapper is all the rest. this isn't currently done in the
attached samples.
--=-=-=
Content-Type: application/octet-stream
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=init.d.tgz
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Description: init.d.tgz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--=-=-=
Cyrille.
--
home: mailto:clefevre@poboxes.com UNIX is user-friendly; it's just particular
work: mailto:Cyrille.Lefevre@edf.fr about who it chooses to be friends with.
--=-=-=--
To Unsubscribe: send mail to majordomo@FreeBSD.org
with "unsubscribe freebsd-arch" in the body of the message
Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?ofuds4pk.fsf>