Date: Wed, 12 Feb 2014 12:12:57 +0200 From: Kimmo Paasiala <kpaasial@icloud.com> To: Hiroki Sato <hrs@freebsd.org> Cc: freebsd-net@FreeBSD.org Subject: Re: gifconfig_gifX not working with cloned_interfaces? Message-ID: <C4C135FC-FE0D-4BE4-B282-4C0F8C4938A6@icloud.com> In-Reply-To: <20140212.065059.1470588740590268007.hrs@allbsd.org> References: <CA%2Bq%2BTcqccvZkts4TGB8QSn_YsNXoCCt%2BWkOZfNdJp2Z%2BYThEMA@mail.gmail.com> <BDD51EA3-06FE-431C-84D9-8FE3671BD05A@icloud.com> <F73EF686-ECA1-4F70-9D15-7D8C336A4FB7@icloud.com> <20140212.065059.1470588740590268007.hrs@allbsd.org>
next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
[-- Attachment #1 --]
On 11.2.2014, at 23.50, Hiroki Sato <hrs@freebsd.org> wrote:
> Kimmo Paasiala <kpaasial@icloud.com> wrote
> in <F73EF686-ECA1-4F70-9D15-7D8C336A4FB7@icloud.com>:
>
> kp>
> kp> On 22.12.2013, at 12.05, Kimmo Paasiala <kpaasial@icloud.com> wrote:
> kp>
> kp> >
> kp> > On 22.12.2013, at 12.01, Olivier Cochard-Labbé <olivier@cochard.me>
> kp> > wrote:
> kp> >
> kp> >> On Sat, Dec 21, 2013 at 9:27 PM, Kimmo Paasiala <kpaasial@icloud.com>
> kp> >> wrote:
> kp> >>>
> kp> >>> FreeBSD 10.0-RC2 r259413 i386.
> kp> >>>
> kp> >>> I have this set up in rc.conf:
> kp> >>>
> kp> >>> cloned_interfaces="gif0"
> kp> >>> gifconfig_gif0="88.xxx.xxx.xxx 62.yyy.yyy.yyy"
> kp> >>> ifconfig_gif0_ipv6="inet6 2001:14b8:aaa:bbb::2 2001:14b8:aaa:bbb::1
> kp> >>> prefixlen 128”
> kp> >>>
> kp> >>> I’m not using gif_interfaces=“gif0” since it’s deprecated as per
> kp> >>> the warning messages spewed by the rc(8) scripts.
> kp> >>>
> kp> >>> However this does not work properly The ‘ifconfig gif0 tunnel
> kp> >>> 88.xxx.xxx.xxx 62.yyy.yyy.yyy’ does not get executed. It looks to me
> kp> >>> that the tunnel set up is only performed when gif0 is listed in
> kp> >>> gif_interfaces.
> kp> >>>
> kp> >>> I can work around this by doing this instead of the 'gifconfig_gif0'
> kp> >>> line:
> kp> >>>
> kp> >>> ifconfig_gif0=“ tunnel 88.xxx.xxx.xxx 62.yyy.yyy.yyy”
> kp> >>>
> kp> >>
> kp> >> Hi,
> kp> >>
> kp> >> You can configure gif interface like a standard interface (without
> kp> >> using gifconfig_), here is an example:
> kp> >>
> kp> >> cloned_interfaces="gif0 gif1"
> kp> >> ifconfig_gif0="inet 10.0.24.2/24 10.0.24.4 tunnel 10.0.23.2 10.0.34.4
> kp> >> up"
> kp> >> ifconfig_gif1_ipv6="inet6 2001:db8:24::2 prefixlen 64 tunnel
> kp> >> 2001:db8:23::2 2001:db8:34::4 up"
> kp> >>
> kp> >> Regards,
> kp> >>
> kp> >> Olivier
> kp> >
> kp> > Hi,
> kp> >
> kp> > Yes I know. I did note that in my workaround for the problem. However,
> kp> > the rc.conf(5) manual page claims that gifconfig_gifX should still
> kp> > work and that’s why I’m reporting the issue.
> kp> >
> kp> > -Kimmo
> kp> >
> kp>
> kp> Hello,
> kp>
> kp> Has anyone had time to look at this issue? I could try to come up with
> kp> a fix myself but I’d first like to know what is the proper way
> kp> configure gif(4) interfaces with FreeBSD 10. If gif_interfaces is
> kp> deprecated then is gifconfig_gifX also deprecated? If gifconfig_gifX
> kp> is also deprecated then this is a documentation issue and also the
> kp> rc(8) scripts should warn about using it like they do now warn about
> kp> gif_interfaces. If gifconfig_gifX is still valid then something must
> kp> be done about the handling of cloned_interfaces in rc.conf.
>
> gifconfig_gifN is also deprecated. Combination of gif_interfaces and
> gifconfig_gifN still works, but it should be rewritten with
> cloned_interfaces and ifconfig_IF. I will add an warning message to
> gifconfig_gifN, too.
>
> -- Hiroki
Hello,
Thanks for the information. I think the rc.conf(5) manual page needs updating as well for FreeBSD 10. It now says:
gif_interfaces
(str) This variable is deprecated in favor of
cloned_interfaces. Set to the list of gif(4) tunnel inter‐
faces to configure on this host. A gifconfig_⟨interface⟩
variable is assumed to exist for each value of interface.
The value of this variable is used to configure the link
layer of the tunnel according to the syntax of the tunnel
option to ifconfig(8). Additionally, this option ensures
that each listed interface is created via the create option
to ifconfig(8) before attempting to configure it.
This should be reworded so that it says that gifconfig_<interface> is also a deprecated variable and also mention that it does not work with cloned_interfaces (the reason for my PR). Also it should be mentioned that the proper way to configure the tunnel part of the gif(4) interface is to use ifconfig_gifN=“tunnel my.ip their.ip”. Maybe it’s also worth repeating the information in the gif(4) manual page?
-Kimmo
[-- Attachment #2 --]
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJS+0kwAAoJEFvLZC0FWRVpQ+0H/0GG383qDXMA0V5IhyszlNg4
LytcrXlkE3JfJ2D/7aU7D6GcrjSbp7N2PHifYhqYPOGdc6QhqrsMKF8zmSC1Jt/4
fr3sek1BE5XV6UaAawSbsWtUz0kX6Fy1uzCoNnPbwvY+2G50uKk/BZ8FL07tA4oW
/pj9/CSdsmGxrhdLZ94DuKtCywEH+99im1ezYBwUVd7dY6YVuw+eTyyNKCBDE5kI
AvqHTPMYpE9ihbNFFvZLOg7Gdu3a0kCXAVAHVn28/xBFPRsmbddSXGqsfGyBIsdw
qLPn4a551OmFahcwTpxb3TKBz8gRwUfMZ66cl93OsFPKANAzftaSwNu1Uvsf+h8=
=2n5u
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?C4C135FC-FE0D-4BE4-B282-4C0F8C4938A6>