Date: Fri, 2 Jun 2000 19:59:53 -0700 From: Jeremy Lea <reg@FreeBSD.ORG> To: "David O'Brien" <obrien@FreeBSD.ORG> Cc: ports@FreeBSD.ORG Subject: Re: Proposal for USE_* directives in Mk/bsd.port.mk Message-ID: <20000602195953.H302@shale.csir.co.za> In-Reply-To: <20000508140442.B56489@dragon.nuxi.com>; from obrien@FreeBSD.ORG on Mon, May 08, 2000 at 02:04:43PM -0700 References: <20000430105058.B309@shale.csir.co.za> <20000430181355835.KOJS.890.t-mta4.odn.ne.jp@mta4.odn.ne.jp> <20000430120305.C309@shale.csir.co.za> <20000507165002718.RWFG.890.t-mta4.odn.ne.jp@mta4.odn.ne.jp> <20000508140442.B56489@dragon.nuxi.com>
next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
Hi,
On Mon, May 08, 2000 at 02:04:43PM -0700, David O'Brien wrote:
> > Is this an official policy?
> >
> > Would you like to show me difference between USE_* and WITH_*(WITHOUT_*)
> > and HAVE_*.
> >
> > Is this policy already documented?
>
> Seconded. I must have missed this. Where is this documented? (providing
> some would have made our email exchange over Vim and GTK not needed)
I've been really busy recently, and haven't had time to get this into
the handbook since sending out the first email below, or the commit
which followed it. I waited a week and got no feedback to the first
message, and the only response to the commit was Jordan complaining
because I broke one port, which happened to break the release build...
Silence is consent...
Regards,
-Jeremy
--
FreeBSD - Because the best things in life are free...
http://www.freebsd.org/
Date: Mon, 10 Apr 2000 02:32:37 -0700
From: Jeremy Lea <reg@FreeBSD.ORG>
To: freebsd-ports@FreeBSD.ORG
Cc: Satoshi Asami <asami@FreeBSD.ORG>
Subject: WITH/WITHOUT options cleanup
Hi all,
I've placed a patch at http://www.freebsd.org/~reg/with.patch, which
cleans up the handling of options in ports. Basically these are any
things the user can define while building ports. We had a mixture of
NO_, WANT_, WITH_, WITHOUT_, DONT_USE_ and USE_, and these were being
tested against YES, yes, NO or no. This was confusing.
This patch makes two kinds of variables:
WITH_FOO - Turns on support for FOO.
WITHOUT_FOO - Turns off support for FOO.
These are boolean, and should only be tested with defined().
If a port autodetect's support then it should use something like:
.if defined(WITH_X11) || (exists(${X11BASE}/lib/libX11.a) \
&& !defined(WITHOUT_X11))
...
.endif
(bsd.port.pre.mk needs to be included before this to get X11BASE).
The patch also removes nearly all occurances of WITH_ variables in
ports, since I want to be able to scan for the options above
automatically. I will write something for the handbook reserving WITH_
and WITHOUT_ as variable names. USE_ should also be reserved for knobs
in bsd.port.mk.
The ports I've not touched are the emacs/mule/canna cancer^H^H^H set
of ports, which have a set of WITH_ options, which should be
CONFIGURE_ARGS+= options. I'm scared of breaking these...
Also, I've not tried to alter any setttings with have multiple values
(like ispell's languages (although these should be WITH_), or glx's
chipset).
Comments please.
-Jeremy
--
FreeBSD - Because the best things in life are free...
http://www.freebsd.org/
To Unsubscribe: send mail to majordomo@FreeBSD.org
with "unsubscribe freebsd-ports" in the body of the message
From: Jeremy Lea <reg@FreeBSD.org>
Date: Sun, 16 Apr 2000 17:19:03 -0700 (PDT)
To: cvs-committers@FreeBSD.org, cvs-all@FreeBSD.org
Subject: cvs commit: ports/archivers/linux_rar Makefile ports/astro/xplanet
Makefile ports/audio/aumix Makefile ports/audio/cdrdao Makefile
ports/audio/lame Makefile ports/audio/lame/patches patch-aa
ports/audio/replay Makefile ports/audio/sox Makefile ...
Sender: owner-cvs-committers@FreeBSD.org
reg 2000/04/16 17:19:03 PDT
Modified files:
archivers/linux_rar Makefile
astro/xplanet Makefile
audio/aumix Makefile
audio/cdrdao Makefile
audio/lame Makefile
audio/lame/patches patch-aa
audio/replay Makefile
audio/sox Makefile
audio/timidity++ Makefile
audio/wmtune Makefile
cad/mars Makefile
chinese/xemacs Makefile
databases/gtksql Makefile
databases/postgresql Makefile
deskutils/gaddr Makefile
devel/glade Makefile
devel/kdevelop Makefile
devel/kdevelop-i18n Makefile
devel/tclreadline Makefile
editors/elvis Makefile
editors/emacs Makefile
editors/emacs20 Makefile
editors/emacs20-dl Makefile
editors/emacs20-dl/pkg DESCR MESSAGE
editors/staroffice5 Makefile
editors/vile Makefile
editors/xemacs20 Makefile
editors/xvile Makefile
emulators/quasi88 Makefile
ftp/curl Makefile
ftp/pavuk Makefile
games/acm Makefile
games/freeciv Makefile
games/quakeforge Makefile
german/staroffice5 Makefile
graphics/aalib Makefile
graphics/gd Makefile
graphics/gd/patches patch-ac
graphics/gimp1 Makefile
graphics/glx Makefile
graphics/py-opengl Makefile
irc/bitchx Makefile
irc/irssi Makefile
irc/xchat Makefile
japanese/dbskkd-cdb Makefile
japanese/jed Makefile
japanese/kterm Makefile
japanese/kterm16c Makefile
japanese/latex2html Makefile
japanese/postgresql Makefile
net/ppxp Makefile
lang/modula-3 Makefile
lang/modula-3-lib Makefile
lang/python Makefile
lang/python+ipv6 Makefile
mail/exim Makefile
mail/exmh2 Makefile
mail/ezmlm-idx Makefile
mail/mutt Makefile
mail/postfix Makefile
mail/zmailer Makefile
math/gnuplot+ Makefile
math/vtk Makefile
misc/gone Makefile
misc/mc Makefile
net/cvsup Makefile
net/mpich Makefile
net/mtr Makefile
net/netatalk-asun Makefile
net/ppxp Makefile
net/rsync Makefile
net/xisp Makefile
security/crack Makefile
security/fwtk Makefile
security/fwtk/patches patch-az
security/heimdal Makefile
security/p5-PGP-Sign Makefile
security/pidentd Makefile
security/ssh Makefile
security/ssh2 Makefile
sysutils/gkrellm Makefile
sysutils/gkrellm/pkg MESSAGE
sysutils/ipsc Makefile
sysutils/xbattbar Makefile
www/netscape3 Makefile
www/netscape4-communicator Makefile
www/udmsearch Makefile
x11/wdm Makefile
x11-wm/afterstep Makefile
x11-wm/afterstep-devel Makefile
x11-wm/afterstep-stable Makefile
x11-wm/blackbox Makefile
x11-wm/fvwm2-i18n Makefile
x11-wm/fvwm95-i18n Makefile
x11-wm/windowmaker Makefile
x11-wm/windowmaker-i18n Makefile
Log:
Standardize all user defined options to the booleans WITH_FOO and
WITHOUT_FOO. Begin the process of reserving these prefixes for user defined
options.
No comment by: ports
Revision Changes Path
1.13 +2 -2 ports/archivers/linux_rar/Makefile
1.5 +11 -11 ports/astro/xplanet/Makefile
1.21 +4 -4 ports/audio/aumix/Makefile
1.16 +7 -8 ports/audio/cdrdao/Makefile
1.10 +3 -3 ports/audio/lame/Makefile
1.4 +1 -1 ports/audio/lame/patches/patch-aa
1.18 +4 -4 ports/audio/replay/Makefile
1.15 +2 -2 ports/audio/sox/Makefile
1.20 +6 -6 ports/audio/timidity++/Makefile
1.8 +3 -3 ports/audio/wmtune/Makefile
1.17 +2 -2 ports/cad/mars/Makefile
1.3 +6 -12 ports/chinese/xemacs/Makefile
1.6 +11 -11 ports/databases/gtksql/Makefile
1.54 +22 -28 ports/databases/postgresql/Makefile
1.7 +3 -3 ports/deskutils/gaddr/Makefile
1.21 +5 -5 ports/devel/glade/Makefile
1.9 +4 -4 ports/devel/kdevelop/Makefile
1.10 +4 -4 ports/devel/kdevelop-i18n/Makefile
1.7 +7 -7 ports/devel/tclreadline/Makefile
1.4 +3 -3 ports/editors/elvis/Makefile
1.45 +2 -2 ports/editors/emacs/Makefile
1.48 +5 -7 ports/editors/emacs20/Makefile
1.17 +3 -5 ports/editors/emacs20-dl/Makefile
1.8 +1 -1 ports/editors/emacs20-dl/pkg/DESCR
1.3 +1 -1 ports/editors/emacs20-dl/pkg/MESSAGE
1.13 +4 -4 ports/editors/staroffice5/Makefile
1.23 +5 -5 ports/editors/vile/Makefile
1.35 +3 -3 ports/editors/xemacs20/Makefile
1.25 +11 -12 ports/editors/xvile/Makefile
1.5 +4 -4 ports/emulators/quasi88/Makefile
1.16 +2 -2 ports/ftp/curl/Makefile
1.17 +3 -3 ports/ftp/pavuk/Makefile
1.23 +3 -4 ports/games/acm/Makefile
1.33 +4 -4 ports/games/freeciv/Makefile
1.5 +6 -6 ports/games/quakeforge/Makefile
1.7 +4 -4 ports/german/staroffice5/Makefile
1.12 +7 -10 ports/graphics/aalib/Makefile
1.22 +4 -4 ports/graphics/gd/Makefile
1.7 +4 -4 ports/graphics/gd/patches/patch-ac
1.68 +6 -9 ports/graphics/gimp1/Makefile
1.7 +5 -5 ports/graphics/glx/Makefile
1.5 +2 -4 ports/graphics/py-opengl/Makefile
1.14 +6 -6 ports/irc/bitchx/Makefile
1.27 +5 -5 ports/irc/irssi/Makefile
1.49 +7 -7 ports/irc/xchat/Makefile
1.4 +5 -7 ports/japanese/dbskkd-cdb/Makefile
1.4 +12 -12 ports/japanese/jed/Makefile
1.25 +6 -11 ports/japanese/kterm/Makefile
1.22 +6 -11 ports/japanese/kterm16c/Makefile
1.6 +4 -4 ports/japanese/latex2html/Makefile
1.13 +20 -25 ports/japanese/postgresql/Makefile
1.13 +3 -3 ports/net/ppxp/Makefile
1.37 +3 -3 ports/lang/modula-3/Makefile
1.23 +3 -3 ports/lang/modula-3-lib/Makefile
1.65 +4 -6 ports/lang/python/Makefile
1.63 +8 -13 ports/lang/python+ipv6/Makefile
1.47 +27 -27 ports/mail/exim/Makefile
1.41 +2 -2 ports/mail/exmh2/Makefile
1.10 +5 -5 ports/mail/ezmlm-idx/Makefile
1.82 +5 -5 ports/mail/mutt/Makefile
1.19 +3 -3 ports/mail/postfix/Makefile
1.4 +2 -2 ports/mail/zmailer/Makefile
1.10 +6 -6 ports/math/gnuplot+/Makefile
1.6 +4 -7 ports/math/vtk/Makefile
1.7 +5 -5 ports/misc/gone/Makefile
1.45 +2 -2 ports/misc/mc/Makefile
1.38 +4 -4 ports/net/cvsup/Makefile
1.16 +6 -9 ports/net/mpich/Makefile
1.23 +3 -3 ports/net/mtr/Makefile
1.15 +6 -6 ports/net/netatalk-asun/Makefile
1.14 +0 -0 ports/net/ppxp/Makefile
1.41 +2 -2 ports/net/rsync/Makefile
1.4 +2 -2 ports/net/xisp/Makefile
1.16 +3 -3 ports/security/crack/Makefile
1.19 +2 -2 ports/security/fwtk/Makefile
1.2 +1 -1 ports/security/fwtk/patches/patch-az
1.14 +5 -12 ports/security/heimdal/Makefile
1.11 +9 -9 ports/security/p5-PGP-Sign/Makefile
1.31 +4 -4 ports/security/pidentd/Makefile
1.94 +15 -17 ports/security/ssh/Makefile
1.96 +15 -17 ports/security/ssh2/Makefile
1.7 +4 -5 ports/sysutils/gkrellm/Makefile
1.2 +1 -1 ports/sysutils/gkrellm/pkg/MESSAGE
1.6 +7 -7 ports/sysutils/ipsc/Makefile
1.4 +2 -2 ports/sysutils/xbattbar/Makefile
1.40 +8 -6 ports/www/netscape3/Makefile
1.65 +5 -5 ports/www/netscape4-communicator/Makefile
1.6 +6 -6 ports/www/udmsearch/Makefile
1.37 +4 -4 ports/x11/wdm/Makefile
1.33 +3 -3 ports/x11-wm/afterstep/Makefile
1.42 +2 -2 ports/x11-wm/afterstep-devel/Makefile
1.38 +5 -5 ports/x11-wm/afterstep-stable/Makefile
1.32 +3 -3 ports/x11-wm/blackbox/Makefile
1.20 +4 -5 ports/x11-wm/fvwm2-i18n/Makefile
1.32 +4 -4 ports/x11-wm/fvwm95-i18n/Makefile
1.67 +6 -6 ports/x11-wm/windowmaker/Makefile
1.71 +5 -5 ports/x11-wm/windowmaker-i18n/Makefile
To Unsubscribe: send mail to majordomo@FreeBSD.org
with "unsubscribe freebsd-ports" in the body of the message
Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?20000602195953.H302>