Date: Tue, 6 Aug 2002 14:10:44 +0930 From: Greg 'groggy' Lehey <grog@FreeBSD.org> To: Brian Astill <bastill@sa.apana.org.au> Cc: questions@freebsd.org Subject: Re: Is simplicity despised? WAS: What do we need in a FreeBSD desktop? Message-ID: <20020806044044.GA45553@wantadilla.lemis.com> In-Reply-To: <200208060414.g764EqL15834@tierzero.apana.org.au> References: <00d301c23504$9bbe0c60$0a01a8c0@mswolf> <200207311037.g6VAb5L68944@tierzero.apana.org.au> <20020731094751.A55417@constans.gldis.ca> <200208060414.g764EqL15834@tierzero.apana.org.au>
next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
[-- Attachment #1 --] On Tuesday, 6 August 2002 at 13:01:53 +0930, Brian Astill wrote: > I was intellectually offended by the response to my suggestion that there is > a use for a simple instrument such as the text editor le. > Apparently if it isn't comprehensive and complicated it is to be despised as > a "toy". > Does that mean that users of FreeBSD are to become elitist intellectual > snobs, discarding on principle that which is easy to use and understand? > There is a precept that I embrace, called > KEEP IT SIMPLE - STUPID! > > Shouldn't we all use the simplest and easiest method to accomplish a task, > not deliberately choose the complex "over-kill" alternative? If there's one thing that you need to learn early on, it's a good editor. I did install le just to see what it was like. I think the average user would find it harder to use than Emacs. The reason for this is simple: people don't read documentation. Emacs gives you the documentation where you need it, in the menus. le may do so, but if it does, it's hiding it well. Take a look at the first two attachments, showing the top and the bottom of the window which it displays once you give it a file name. There's nothing at the top, and the bottom, apart from being almost illegible, gives little useful information. I certainly don't know how to use it without finding the man page. It took me some experimentation to find out how to stop the program. By contrast, look at the Emacs window in which I'm writing this reply (third and fourth attachments). I'd show the pull-down help window if I could; try it for yourself. That's only the start, of course. To reply to the mail message, I pass the message to an already running emacs via emacsclient. I could write the reply with le as well, but how do I adjust the lines so that they're not too long or too short? Now's the time to read the man page, which tells me that I can turn off the colours with the -b flag, but it doesn't seem to have anything beyond basic editing capability. By contrast, Emacs does automatic line breaking for me, and if I have rearranged the text, a single keystroke reformats the paragraph. Why should I ever want to use le? Greg -- When replying to this message, please copy the original recipients. If you don't, I may ignore the reply. For more information, see http://www.lemis.com/questions.html See complete headers for address and phone numbers [-- Attachment #2 --] GIF87a, 66 (( cc ## ҿ7/p`t m(p/ l eM - _t o p. b; ( d ҿ 7pY (( M e _ Yc # ( pW (_ c #C( ^ f^T(( Đc#(6U)$ v p m _ P 4 Y| gp T _ d\ OL c # ( T , [ D ߙ(( c#( d\ ą c # ,d `Th( P Y((T t , , @DȰÇ#JHŋ3jȱǏ CIɓ(S Y\I͛8sɳϟ@li@/*]ʴӧPJJիXjʵׯ`ÊKٳhӪ]V RHʝK ̺x˷߿LÈ+^̸ǐ#KL}1%jt!шMӨS^3C9 amָs6 do#T~PQ3_GGNu߸}dمkNi'<[}\/ާ/A7sMg% B 4[o j pw~NavHx!v"h3zMG{5c/H]v& D# bK"iMB)GZ8XZL3h]˱Q`hA"F'U24Q'BmTs %X6ۚE!gd+"pfz'&ީazlzgBv9ŨV"pIgVJtr*jNy&ezb8VS։ɫgA֬ŚoI-ۊm wG!gS&pł*FSG;klJo1W<mJ#,[DjD/Wg-,*[/6@3Ϯ.%TGL7PG-TWmICSG% `- mhlp-tmx|߀.7^H]7G.Wng^_.褗n騧ꬷ.n/ī6犣]7G/Wo/<ʉ{.v ߧN^矞~aK~6~?G۞Ɣ/觾o#]@hOL!C(ܑЃ0g:&6 p!z="$\)(#i7#ZXL z1`v?u-bNho:d!8F|`l#w2~za01oL(E5ω<l"1~$&7Y@f, ۓR"U)4FЈܠ 8DQr4-S9K[Rh%/ʱR$$qK e3a6rs87JvQdc7 Liֲ,1]\:0,&;Iw&2IzӎO&;9Pem;Y?&Ԭ873t`:ZQqs.ͅ'B%ԤgL!cԖ#E3IQztBgA)Ѧ:գ[iʠNIUPRnԒ+ud=)MD!)FZYW&46ͪ zP}O `ymqq4&U NϒT&?5*>''hhj})yCb4mZ*FT)$fάֳ^ޚ/iAWRǕe[1Ѝ. ;*OKr"po9z7MzާRkCl{KG|oHG8F8nsd }ꮟk$-mB };~k٥SIKںpkkNi2qQ\vq~KJ{u46*Ek=~ tZcvތk:βylN}-JDXf|I%N*|3n-L{Ub+@5ôl G>3V~Vː!Y*ke2Fxo7YGfԦ,-h!MYWnV3E#M=r@eMkcN'zVG䌞щl+GPF*UKFkUͮ2kM:7bǎ/ouN2Nmn#u7e˜z+Z][ Eݘo}ߵ"SO+5).ll{0EsbqǸx#d' :o:;9G ; [-- Attachment #3 --] GIF87a 66(( cc ## C/p`t m(p/ l eM - _b o tt bi f ( d CpY (( M e _ Yc # ( pW (_ c #C( ^ f^T(( Đc#(6 U)$ v p m _ P 4 Y| gp T _ d\ OL c # ( T [ D ߙ(( c#( d\ ą c # d `Th( P Y((T t , P *DX Ç#JHŋ3jȱǏ CIɓ(S\ɲ˗0cv,h@6\Pϟ@ JѣH*]JM.!ӫXjʵׯ`,Ps TT˶۷pʝKS9w=h߿LĻ7sװǐ#KL$RV̹ϠCcX3ƢS^ͺ눤۸svZN|g,μi"`@ŧBνw4Wϋӫ_Ͼ˟OϿ (h&})YF(VhF }f (aF`{+*_- b(#-69!,dzNƧdPVi#zS\v^eg{Y&Y~(*9e3bf2y%oڗ,y}7 9`rfTY(U"Z^F* &Cʷg hhwiҩ*~ߦZHxjj{"gfJ YOV?Y#:jdIybd:!.v{x䵶mW8-*[oѮ* ,ihz/[.̭kng!*#o&ˋí6l`f"ʾK ǜ*n<+ʫR+̟)rt'{;5KZ֖s{dK-2u &٭JͳӠ~<7w}%{:?oxِGe]8|rҟ+:a3IְJ$Ӫۧf!s.Ox2;>/Ÿ&s.K.O7/_o&qc~´.`y/kzn7 Ghx2s'-!ɠ7z GH(L W0gH8̡w²$F6"H"HL&:P\"*ZX̢.z`H2hL6pH:)@>:~ IBL"F:$'IJZ̤&7Nzd(HQL*WV,gIKK2ɥ.ui]0IbL2f:Ќ4IjZ̦6^nӛ8IrL:vS4f@ ; [-- Attachment #4 --] GIF87a @ Y 0@??BB:FF>ZZX\\Waa`bbbe^hhcssstyy{lN0fjȯ}θӼӽɛ &pY (( M e _ Y(( c # ( pW (_ c #C( ^ f^T(( Đc#(6 U)$ v p m _ P 4 HY L gp T _ d\ OL ( c # ( T [ D ߙ(( c#( d\ ą L# d `Th( P Y((T t , H`*\ȰÇ#JHŋ3jȱǏIɓ(S\ɲ 0cʜyp͛8sɳϟ@ JѣH*]ʴiКNJJիXjZׯ`ÊKٳhӪ]˶۷pʝKݻxF鲯߿LO[+^̸ǐ8˘3k#fglt4<+o^ͺuaG5M<i՝Nծ4?u>.p:Nj?˯۶~t/w{ݱ7|$]ur58E{QhaN~q`>Sh,&wmh܇i8S݇#!#6(d/dM(LޘދSw^@B^\(f|2ʧ0 @5] o6h]9&<eXg;yo&ʢs[y6#j=!jJݗV~N'hj·ʞyHNԫ+,&,uŲFiQfv¸k覫+k ,l' 4G,Wlgw ,$l(K<n,0,4l+߬<@mrBmH'PG-TCtXg\B`-]_MhfpǍ`ux?ww}7\|}+8Č-ym. `;1$Mg2NxO.;t_nN3:ǸǮ'q[;SO}Σ^yw_~n~ミ+7?~=كz /oSw'Hˠjy$mz{ ǽ5p{ԠAȅP( P4TCω{`݇=;~8Eq+xApwEt '^BbEeQ=\G-|푌\D>юQd&*g#CMΓwd^: ʘj%*WVFL,5 Y%.wT汗&t)b3j<2Yq=Ќ4IjZ̦6nz8IrL:u<Izf~ @JЂMBІ:DYͨF7юHґ?+)JWҙ0^*Ӛڴc4Nw:JĂR ,@[BdZ2`uI-Q aj 2zDEu,`NF V-Pv,q5J~5e,ZT-pV-fEؽ`)Jcuh `իZ| H ' +N9֫Hի(@BO ,0vLe*c@Sfn% pV `!++B+f+jQk:T |1`a]X-` I]C.,Ԑ)+l۽@(A ~K<2``G+@,w+ב0F 5sk?pb~KdvRb 6Wc:~k TVxo)p@>2o u+f1{1f ƢMm\ m^cY%r۸ X0@-/U]Lsw/M7,/U'X)p R \x̬.v1]S?rUY ^Y@|^K}1A2;"Jtk] !Lܲ.Z<PqWj y=3MvFDD+4~m$ v5z;9{bAv}FS p2ۘ2q[Õ_oYTg:]s s, < o g`;<7 i7g`9_;v6ɉL<*WyfN- OۜY$ z~G': M|7$AI9:賾`߹Ɏ `|4Fjvnnr}k~.x/w|n}-=t[~sJ|ӝ.nc] ^nl9|5A<=p܉sAwb|x3|w7cC_ 6o}'np}6~k,upgz~z|}g0{cgh9Wm-r-w@A047xm/ ẊG|Z?fo) ]v3}_oV&n%p uv&x`+Xq 2(Gi7x{uU;{{zwnxPJf|in7Vh8t t Ѕl6sXp0~ Us1p8(0p.#Xe~|rHX.j32i2X4aj7Lgho_1k7 hU_׆Ǎ76^=:Hr|8a>[waYB@'c:nΘ9ok"U1Ս_zW~6]m'=hǎJSW\xkhev4feC(qk ZVՍ8aU$ 66S")9|2ȓeՁ"`pVVZ/1e8VHCN 2\bӎf\`iZ3W tB%S]yRkٖrYT8vRqyzLy~)L}K1Oy٘TQ9Yy䙠9TyٚӔ9Yyٛ9YyɛV71љYyؙٜٝ)y虞깞ٞ9 0 Sws 9I9ٛ|9*)1Qjڡ)*!z)$-0 1Iԉũɣ j& ٟF*1?J6Jzj7!z jE TUj_dfZ*IiʥZڥW:,!lZ,z+jJ ʤʟ4;5jI:'j )ʨn*9j\XʠqjvZڦڨʧD:ڛ#TʩwzW* 9Z 9 jʦVzڧ ::.ZszZJjຮƺڧ>Jjگʫ ;*䚰ymzAˠڬj:ʯuʧ٪{ꨮJݪ2K:;#** *K>{jOtjE*3:6KE[=1e˴ zz`ʶ\;#ZE{`WkعH۷Z˞K^^噸;霌k;۹˛9{yIڢ/+{RY5j91$Zo[K{++*۶[F+jۮӛjb{~:{V&[ī<EU+zJ 㛹ٳܻ%[LK[j ,|k0*w/Ы[ìls$k^Ƌ[w/.܋6ܽS riKZFĉ¾C 7,,K˲f+'˭"=Xǿs:|hLN<'Cܺ,:Kܪ&+Dˮn;t>Ə;Lq{Ƶˏ[J˟#˚Kʼ|̿<Ԝ;,{;KΛ̡RJى<Il,\|ZϐKΖc҉*0@̾}|Ul`+운 (#- Ѝ;['MR+qͬ>ldl.=;z+vL$Ml;|ڲܱBMX]0z7L|nNN^Y4O;yL#=;MIۿք-|̹Ņ9jk,ܠC͐ٶ͚٠]p}̔}ڨ=-٩ڰ,}۩ڵμ۾·ۦֿ} ; [-- Attachment #5 --] GIF87a>
