Date: Wed, 08 Aug 2007 13:50:53 -0400 From: Mike Tancsa <mike@sentex.net> To: Dag-Erling =?iso-8859-1?Q?Sm=C3=B8rgrav?= <des@des.no> Cc: Takeharu KATO <takeharu1219@ybb.ne.jp>, freebsd-current@freebsd.org Subject: Re: ichwd for ICH8 Message-ID: <200708081750.l78HoaUY047803@lava.sentex.ca> In-Reply-To: <86y7gmkolf.fsf@ds4.des.no> References: <46337B06.9080102@ybb.ne.jp> <46338C0F.9000608@ybb.ne.jp> <4633932A.8080602@ybb.ne.jp> <86tzuxni1b.fsf@dwp.des.no> <200707061723.l66HNYSe037055@lava.sentex.ca> <86ir86hqhc.fsf@ds4.des.no> <200707262035.l6QKZtnd067391@lava.sentex.ca> <86abtihk6h.fsf@ds4.des.no> <200707262338.l6QNcL1T068284@lava.sentex.ca> <86hcnq900e.fsf@ds4.des.no> <200707270038.l6R0cLNV068524@lava.sentex.ca> <8664462p1b.fsf@ds4.des.no> <200707271037.l6RAbc2Q071412@lava.sentex.ca> <86fy2v2x9e.fsf@ds4.des.no> <200708071529.l77FTpsO040934@lava.sentex.ca> <86y7gmkolf.fsf@ds4.des.no>
next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
--=====================_1726394468==_ Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1"; format=flowed Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable At 11:55 AM 8/8/2007, Dag-Erling Sm=C3=B8rgrav wrote: >Mike Tancsa <mike@sentex.net> writes: > > Dag-Erling Sm=C3=B8rgrav <des@des.no> writes: > > > I've tested the driver under -CURRENT on a couple more machines, with > > > the same result everywhere: it probes and attaches and seems to work > > > fine, but the box does not reboot. > > kldload ichwd, watchdogd -t 20;killall -9 watchdogd and nada ? > >Precisely. > > > I can boot one of my working RELENG_6 boxes on current and test if you > > think it is some version issue. > >That would be great! Very strange indeed. My RELENG_6 box reboots=20 just fine with your version and the version from=20 the PR. However, the box fails to reboot running=20 with a CURRENT kernel on either version of the watchdog. On a chance, I tried a trick I used to have to do=20 ages ago in order to get the driver to work. I added debug.acpi.disabled=3D"sysresource" to /boot/loader.conf and then it worked on the CURRENT kernel. i.e.=20 kldload /tmp/ichwd.ko,watchdogd -t 20;killall -9=20 watchdogd.... ~20 sec later, the box reboots=20 running a CURRENT. Without that in loader.conf, the box does not reboot. I _dont_ have to add=20 debug.acpi.disabled=3D"sysresource" on RELENG_6 on=20 the same box for the ichwd to work as expected. dmesg.txt attached the for same machine-- running CURRENT, one from RELENG_6 --=====================_1726394468==_ Content-Type: application/octet-stream; name="dmesg.txt.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="dmesg.txt.gz" H4sICDcCukYAC2RtZXNnLnR4dADtW2tv27gS/R4g/2Fu94sDyLaolx9Ig3UcO/HdODEsp1tgsSho iXK0tS2tHmm9v/4OSUmWU6dN2i7g3spplYjiDIdnhpwRD3x8dIw//SDcRP7iPoGacwKk09Hqmqq2 YHbPYBgxdm5fwCQK/mJO0vi0d6uj4LWtiqsurpa4tsVVPO0QcdXEVfTpGMdHkH34OFO2YOskhsCD BG/v1v4Di2I/2fCWPl36XhCtfdqA3nIJYvgYIhaz6IG5aFRuph8DxfaFHycsYi4kEXXZikbvuZry fIZBunZp4gfrknSrodb7d9Pp4GYGv6hd+B019NIFQBuI1iV6V9NhcDEDjo40f+UmdO3E9Fe2qics ThoxzoJ9bDi020zjqBlHTjPexE1fb1tNJ1iF/pI1oyBF646PZv6KOWgH3sArv62ZxivwIvZ3ytbO Bgjp6KStwdU/8HeKACAUKqI/uevCCEWWtekJ9IOI1WbjEw2wHYqPZagqwK+gNYh+ifI1jehmw7Tq Y7yx2lbdWdI45jInfBq3iKe/htfw6pKtU3/NhP5XACMXG9WPlqcB2AkLQ3+9wBaNCw0ZTVL0wGv1 49xjc2/ueafDyZ3yZjxQLgbKxB4oM7uvjO2pMukNlHF/oPTftpXeZNRX7MFEGc+m+OSSP+kp/fHt G+w242K6pfSvh9d39pVyMbOVXn8yUsbjt8rwLaqyUS3+1/CiXM1mymysTM4HZ2WDNLSI6XP3FPvp ytR+c6Ep49sb5cJ+159co31vlYHNJbkS3qX/lljKx9kEzbnoj4Wu3viiPEFNJSr/nN68Va4/7cFH JKfXvauheMSdEkOITg2p854uWJcjFjG6hBVbBdEGOIbEMDSdGJqB3lENA8bn6Av6QP2iF3ZSO5pl qkbHghouGVN24ogAxxFmdL5E7aejm9ngGl2ko429q7MioJv2eNKFcbpM/DAKHBbHQQT2BtfGCi5Y guuZuWgcD4QYLXfCVIXauT056Ur9o4su8KDjTwjUersPyPGRH9DQd3Cl9O/pesGjI3sMSQBm8RxO 3/DFHKwxItUz8KO/Y1DruJiwZRXgeo/mAY3c46P3c5cATQB/r9KPOLITbcIkiAMvwUFO+e8PNGIg m88+kadO6KsFIDkeT3X7YzS7mg56F38WLZPgA7rtPE0SFKl5/kfmnjxapxz9ukfjpLxWdbPVMQ2z vFZ5xEi97xKUj7hZmlGf+wmIez5NvSHlcFmeQRhECS42Q23X+XXOrRZmIQroGBQXjkdfnZUeiQEw 1rxyB77LZZb1g3USBUshwtXsSngYbrjH4eKfDKbDd/asN7uz0bKEOvfHRy578B32Tt52YSuY9cCN FuN/jQqsAzKEx+qXwCLPspHsSnydjeSzYB2EIXMR79xv9pKxMIv/MnCh488Lv14FcVKf9Ecwj3x3 wYrIdTweuY7n7QoWckIkjYVeoVDqJaXnO2pxgci5gNZuqJmUFCJP6SRSp/YsncaOTu0pnbh562LX ySTdiNcmgAUJdHCRAxYhPm74cRJEuNmDI323xB1PgQe573VxqbfUhqo3ROWAmxhHRWot67AzHf1C R4Eu38vq/BfiiwkCW9ptkZR4a7vjiY+Cf1KtaOV/YivfcIFYpcmrBZ5abs0fl6Pezax+fdv/bcB3 xKx1u0XKhtHN8LYLNUx4ZhdtIGgWJoWtvThCguEZdzHvBC5bQgcTmD2oa9cTBTMNnwzCMvSjlZj8 cNB5i9ioFgKD/0wFzke3NpzvNmvSq/qzvGrueFV/yqv68RFbiVyRF1OT6W2T79pww5IPAZaMOKs1 5kiet/L8VQerYTb0wiuaRBoLhMIrlLQL/Emn8ArZeoW0vMIrrb1eyY0b8KS1ZglQ18WiIkbI1S4i T1pd4nYt1tVZ1vOP4eh6Npj+WUw69lfhkkfjaoWA3/Wms7OdoXSorYM8luXOIJJdLo4BiQWLQKws Zjwhlt7LlX53hTjXsJZHeXw9uLPPSwuinORUkeU6EgYsBUo+7JRXe6b4cXjmzdv4TOP5MwxAvUI0 78+fRziu8C5piAHTeREXINRFQZAANisgC+dOE992UIoLqE1+UYSHgMgB4vlWTxbz8MFP7vEmwtru gZdtCq75pYcPP/AXFTkh8gIALQlgK4ujzi6AZBdAsh9A8hjAZxiQAUjy/vsBJN8KICn0vARA7QUA GhJAMwOwvQugtgugth9A7TGAzzAgA1DL++8HUPtWALVCz0sA1F8AoCYB1PfkFwRQ3wVQ3w+g/hjA ZxiQAajn/fcDqH8rgHqh57kAsmwPlMO2tbZKLs+bU6iN+lctOQ98/9mZS54zMI0aWXbAP1ve/m2x tcWU7d8W2b5t0ejCB+on/PWMFy0iw+L72QL3cEjD3J68K387cSFIk0+E8h4DDmhW2WSAi3Z+vkHX vHGnBsrhY6Ie5ZujWOAiSHOghfxLgMNBWLGPG4+CQMuDYKt08Nkg0J4KAqPQ0y4HQfvpIOC1hfHl QkVXH5W0xlOFCprwsKBZIf3mslcXMCc+jg2uH4dLuikWJZElBikVieq2SGyVikQeblnAqca2HCnv gkZhocGLDPKttRIh0jiib2slVduaoW+N29ZKWFjtrZXMT4z7cq3kZT23tZIfU5HruZ9Gdm+fn0jZ T9hfLHDeNXORUIEvUknuIhlvPHLh7mLcw0nv2z6JJ7DwWjhh3bPwSlqipSVaWrzFUOdyi53v8Q4a VkryOLx4z5r1wLmn6IolqPIFTtqV9ygfeSSUPBIhn4iQxyLZy1dpkjZq0PdP0lAdeZjheGI6zBB3 rCXuHDk5R94xecd0cUflHfXKO6S63SF1b0/dg5BoO5CEj0scbNM+AxPJe+yK6J+BieQ9SiJZIGxL aAXs8fluJY22PlWBey4/UTv1lkEYbuTzfeDqIoJ0zxQRpAo4LOyOaaP0Ai6VbSOeJu/nUv9vbCOO w0q6oea3VUM7KcawVFRuGRLq8kEK1yIDDnI9Z6VechBxnsfPaGRDSe5x2iratyDiFsIHIJZpqjt7 Xv92LMwrAdEWQMiIMMBb0kUsNsOSxVJdsgkZSJUKn3ccLFn+rPQGtZIndtnyRukgWuXr/jYUm9z0 diz96QcyQp0sPJ223MWcTnZPeTYP16Hvwu10zHtt9YYhd0VII4rwL+WE1pijPM5ONNAy4ansxDaz V4y6nWNJm+iNGYKjBg9+lKQYfpkUxqCQeS1OEs7EpAlP2WvPX6ScKuHg6WJ0fw1zP1nRkJMmYRTM 5dMY1FxMGLqiG9F9zoCteSp0RabiFl/K2g04YGiQMDn3llj2uusVyNEMubnY6YvZlE5dYyxKnPfA cKFsRMGmwipmzvHRkMYJjCb4NydFsFqhS/8ftNZmThrxU9heHAeOL3geTmHxI3CsaBBZ6mLCbVk6 6YzPEWFGFzRhYM/0ttompGeD3uj1BmcyeKlWX1HOKInNjphonThZ703Eud0vBK5puubL9z/HRy4V Ic+PS/jaBxUSGi0wL6mwTNccQ1fu1eN+v3Q6Ahcj+zdx5nEGQ37wDBd+hBkVeg63Guy+Paqb+faR KSHieEQdnzdjTnWtYw/Byp61LK2t4+RqxLQ0rWW2DTCJBvMNzhMBS4IIU6Rmmldg6XZzBp2WZvT5 aXe04UUfFogrjr4smrwoWEHqxd0mGtBE8GJCj4/kz++8InLZPF00+GJruDwlYjS8fhVvYszEQRo5 7BVUPON+npE85hl10tU7PzLPaFY8Y8UzVjxjxTNWPOMh0HsHY0jFM1Y844t5RtXgPCMORHZ5Rl6U JRA4WOhHPLuI+/g1qYjKiqisiMqKqKyIyoqorIjKiqisiMqKqKyIyoqorIjKiqj8V4jKn4ItTGmU FHQsYJrd7u075N5nqVg5bqZq6+msIRsaambLwvy2VtoKOfmJGMUfnTd8mhF9AaP4e296M7q57EIT i7pYRHcYBSGLlhteQwh5Xrzwn+ngenBz+c6qvsJYkrYaWt2e9c6vB+IbjLP7FP6bLkGzQG11jU7X JE8xi/6KLpilPWYWg/lfOwxjRSoeCKl4Ou+cSU7xdE6MM341zw6NVWybHb2j/ays4stowooUrEjB ihSsSMF/gxS0MlLQOlBScNizZ9V3DLfHUVqjc1DU3U/C1X1fZu6rTvUPn4/7vuzbN4B0yJzb92XY vgGkQ+bVvi+L9g0g/Vjc2c/OlH0VUXYQ/Fj2OGPDlOIks0Rk7c+EX8lqlcuIQ2C1fi4a68us1Q9F Un2ZkPoC/3SIdJN87zhMsulfYJb+P7mkw6COqq+UfaevlP0PifGE4pZSAAA= --=====================_1726394468==_--
Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?200708081750.l78HoaUY047803>