Skip site navigation (1)Skip section navigation (2)
Date:      Fri, 28 Nov 2025 11:58:02 +0100
From:      Marco Orsatti <marco.dmc12@gmail.com>
To:        infoomatic <infoomatic@gmx.at>
Cc:        virtualization@freebsd.org
Subject:   Re: bhyve + swtpm + W11
Message-ID:  <B4F039A5-0C21-4AA9-B76B-B41221BED8BB@gmail.com>
In-Reply-To: <036cdd7b-1afb-4cd2-9f9a-48d23cc7449a@gmx.at>
References:  <031fe2e6-eae6-4d4a-8bce-cd7eadd0b5a6@netfence.it> <dc5aefd6-985f-4408-971c-9347a4f86231@gmx.at> <D9D7A692-3DC4-4E55-B023-8F2BE2205D84@mcrservice.net> <036cdd7b-1afb-4cd2-9f9a-48d23cc7449a@gmx.at>

next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help

[-- Attachment #1 --]
The Windows 11 test VM automatically detected the TPM (IBM vendor):


[-- Attachment #2 --]
PNG


IHDRS<
iCCPICC ProfileHTSϽ7H'&z轉JHB ""XFdXbb> :,.μ[ogoϿ9랬(H)z0ba@PX.&[fZ<
E9D(:Ƹ"q.!ԯ8W4ɷQV<4)<1ISDY@D<n
Ce)	(D533rFhI}fw:)Ljr8)R˔98efHfr*Gg:zfgHY2TJf?9q:3,rّ3aqV4oؓ5l
(?ϖFp :XZ[zDl/KzCfw{ksS#/djJkgc\i.QF4+EH/PqCgX@0v4c.If<DKł\q|[5˰`N§%D?5˪E_<K*>]PhJy>eE4.0fhoB@$L A!XA)*u 8Z	p\W
p<}`# Q iA)d
1!W
¡8(J*@PT_݇a-4#0V5`f,8)p6J>g+~	"A6b0O$G1)A*	iG[H
ahDalrzLӂ9nj`b)Xu)	bS
>1y q8?\.
W[ۉkuzpQ<7ŻC|.?D!h	>xPAh "$<'D'bG\JH%$y!ɅIJ#"UHIHdddtded2+e*e\LV =	d	yy?|BP)\J=,	,M\-˓]![-"{S5Hէ
u+9Gn\q^Qy||zKC
xoB^
4KqikhAE"[1MTb−RjJ}tn@g3wcs4笛4朏j|f;c*ot**U1&aUwW}U+Q;@V7QW/P߫~U}TCSWC]+Mff)a-@\`T21Fյ%{uutV4<%2uuu;uG
?5h52T6d6>2e63Ӎw0MLRMM¦ӝ=ss
5#[_[Y[ljigaYkJjU[kkum
67|]hvAvk:;؋v82̋XG'?;;:v9ݹyh<y.:.=.}Dן]ܴ8n5nOuyܟYibc=<yvx!^^%^
QUO|t|R|}F|||;~~zl.=\9 "*iI8=(X?XB![Bf
{n^AX!#rc((ITg45:!>cWLYL_E+qqx||tLK(Np.XxrugёDlbLbC'SMb'Hzrq_ya<%,y(%eKp[jE+J&/mw2b23	Dž
t,ͬ%Y="SQ/){k8@/YӖ6JW%F$yyyG/>D~pե&K-}K[Y]kٞ+tW\黲niUk-W~&fM{Fʢ|h,-u^G̏٬۾k	reiEz?YTӷ
7oܵ	Ifueee[3Ko]Rmmmm}mo>QZuڣyu;>}Wnݥ~|oy{Fv~}_ՅםwoPo7J$q`[YӞfzs!pHrů=pHQ;ю@-K[FZS[zlwn?oOh>tr)ҩSNu:rfsQógo;}>>vN_txӥ㗙[_ijw5kǺ[;\oxg^ϩn7u6;wzFݽכwwo~7?\'Oj~7ϾdWէOp^`3ʳZ뇬Nx1KWuu$vdͷߩ}h?|RTk,f	D/_>훈#L:dA	'Dx
UB661O"ЉmTv%MLڂ܈
FMVeXIfMM*iDSASCIIScreenshotۮiTXtXML:com.adobe.xmp<x:xmpmeta xmlns:x="adobe:ns:meta/" x:xmptk="XMP Core 6.0.0">
   <rdf:RDF xmlns:rdf="http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#">;
      <rdf:Description rdf:about=""
            xmlns:exif="http://ns.adobe.com/exif/1.0/">;
         <exif:PixelYDimension>393</exif:PixelYDimension>
         <exif:PixelXDimension>595</exif:PixelXDimension>
         <exif:UserComment>Screenshot</exif:UserComment>
      </rdf:Description>
   </rdf:RDF>
</x:xmpmeta>
W
@IDATxx]ŕ~W˒lEЁQ&m˲,bbub{/rNZB`M"犤-{,	^`;i dyU{>:A>j_g:֬Y3N8@@@@"pV^P@@@@@3   3U<8S    P+t75ϳpK/rZ}gR)9r._}7}I_2}Δo9S	m^NDW/
}Ѕ+D_4:[X  J:2kiڵ/(N*W%[Ok/oȼ'.QǕ##>-!r&#rD;e	(.8RO~ok~
䙴
g?i\Q1T 3A˕-3>?ΣU/f	[.GPD\_Z~[1c2zS'O$H Ӏu/^\Ut{MOΛG/хOS/#=//ӌzʝNDUʰ&i&QNFJ|X9o<Hw饮$^ί-zE|7-2?s7qC˻7uqZFPQv	O|LѓOx?gXnӶ0	N?~ mt[kIݩs@@	?2%S{<%adt	z㼊Bęz݊>{n/}Y)|"vsd[e14ƔiHAv҂әF]U})
sޯRqu~lZi0i'kb`JO>dkA	Tۇ1|Uװ-y޼_x}v|J߄#D@GSy؛̥WBF=9#LHltr=[,bMֶkjK=jLO*ajjC~-{7Pr<"zd>E/cx{|-/\)%ؗs2K_JTGޕ2'{>SC+"p  Pwx<=ɣV>&_ORBSN*P&=ꌌňͧdԙY;
IH9hMC;ZӜLgd;?(buzLM͓ERO>A!+c,R]HJ!gbD]ZjʝtKknJ|;u#?"Έ<&$$.JҖ蟌ndžtjrZsQ=cPQ*.L;fk%tdSQI{yŻcI$>Z湽_VHc';d
Paj}X
=*P󘞻:~vR8;Q*2!g̵K+JWBܖ_v֗pUWW>+^cΜ3{73ڞ%vµD
%Pf͚){6ѕSRt  BvTmAQ@@J:2f*.Vy7/J>'9   %$P%TxT_(lM|>A@@@ &gJ'ATP@@@4q>	>A@@@ߟrxf?NHG꥗^4_:f
   ,@P    	J%@@@@#gC'g*=3)    P@@@<p<@zp3C	P    	J%@@@@#gC'g*=3/gw/H'=Go~^:^{?I5.3gYgo11^zi<_~ď7??}z5|-q57Nc3V})*ߺP@@@ʑ@SO?}ƿƞohљ7蜳ʚSs~A_x?ӬYʑtLҋýigWl7h%H|C4czgwtyЪ[JK[2#35:4WO_gjSMM
]xY3gtItߞKoz׻EUUUe@zy
OC}㟤R]]ϧyќԲp=vz魷Jx<:<_D'IK}iKIաӼ=I\ʲ~C#m@i*l\&BovgRi-  0LDW*o4JoA::uJ>]+҅s酟?)Sǒtw
yG+nu+it(]q]1:N'ҞG#L?BT&E8&esb'.۳6>{6YDS21A@`o&+/g^"GO=?Cg~6qrę;wnx2|JZY\Ck$3D7V1iA|	{ng
-q}	:٥W51FIv5k>ZJ}zk5+n?^@-}]g/
=kZKU<v!b!U%[hAgQZٺH
FИR:ϝRTt1h/Urnn)J},Svw~A.cJ+_/m裷e)5c-4&S2|0@t˜+QFZIڑI7wiK(KlۘO/2`kn@@rwG(sGFg7NZxm9-/PF/]7uV<R~fiA{FlMI=`R|tiǙ.;h84<7g%]==e|g?D*,SbWt9^
} Iɹ^z0l|q~[2%n,Ohzh$KI'
ڪ\Hnl, '3GW4'Ysghh|YT5YshkӿгjK>y#<5S8y!y:!Vu5~ĢQȃ;u2W&qa˯FTnzG+(OQʜ%F`̰UYu7כgdx5N٘dGinm	e)2ydSE'iRgT'  E!3u9{ϟEs`>sYi{wҌ3o|wӯk(}:SS3l:JuIe<rQ"gD)LE^7Ϸ\rze=djRf@@`j˙:쳩?EOHCNXh_9Ug3foϦOB3ԯ~WUZ~=ҏ~#.7SZ2@Q"_#j:yThݖ	??+MCh<BUsj$~4H^VBn(Lle'M9f9F^PR9$YƩlyAʩ6LLA@&3%ɶ0ᚕyJ|Ξ3-q[g4Υ}{w><oJwA7nnz衇s5
uJ^Ś	},q>''nÇOkx
9y̙.'v1G󂋡hSe{Vz-55Wf@gYv=<RG_=Flz>YG^5N.;\}|,6%n?m(@^o@U?y?)W7%f\|MৼS&/lllToTG?J]ty8ɿ^l5ެ<XhgY_  0zϔo}z
w>~0v^zٳ('镗_qU\>ʈ6Ox?yӧe{qXh>hz|&  o;QtM$kFE i>)ēO:}*ztԼ44|o^S8Qʑz8	jw;Y>Ź#"~́~łőZ*2QRх\P9S?|~ϜEN;"g͜M_HI>Dϗ_D)x>w<G>J3Y	   H gCtpxYUTr{{y;EЇ!҇vġzWW_i=ǹydY+5{lzU%IRVda~e)uN$;/BM&!'.DuLfbWf=d
Xꕢ&֔ug D g[ASKwqDy+Tb˿\MxѢK.+jhcZb5
e-OSVu)ěnI,Sp67NmS4DJE>'thi3_9YغQ^+h4_Yx*1!~K#nc"Sq]ca>4Q*@AY<
%J|n荗_3*<[=KO<czПٟGggs?6z/b|>)=)_B9\2Ujnn.aCmf-;M'E7p;Ρ7uvOIGT-s:/YT5u2Ir.'lM!t	3(HHv
r֯~K;	ϤH&×/VSW_}'ɧe~MPZ[kK?9:B2ǞQ&{:3fPKK5\Mg}Z6/j/q2lʛe{J-ۺb>W.wWݘXewHvS*@ΞqeʯvuꕕOA@6vY9\~Zk)ySS4']	n@Za1_0^:4ǶA4/w6t*]7T\VI;ʼmҷeK䍦8(ï׼\>.7(SepNe{OH{|9}dvu7an|Li9S2-_J-
3fM,s鵙_:}oFM(3dF= ~NO(ȋΏg=x˙_)x;y|ʉZTw/o禚lc}NQ/xt8(WmZ9X7&~͙N|qތ;ye}8/m4lDX
XJiDM6=a=#Qp7=8iobkK{̺~ZU}{m{xA5-tqI^/#joEgtwpPcJv!|[Dq!hQ6V?sYnR=E۫[/ЍÍ
r%-˖…1},zTsکsks=mԙ?Q{~أj*O~'PSOO8r_ykNzPV
}&ݘ7 #ѰlZ+em۞/o
Kyt`
Yj*R>*X@}wMFta.<ڙl0[\V۰; wjpƛ\B
f
2Ho8[<sqd=${oT]wgkP>Q5(~;_<e7If0
{fՓ3^;JX0Z>A*@AΔ?nR/^<Mzѯ葓OK6ţW}Y
圿UΔ\F:;;}+>qOz|>í65ll<<tFZV2=aKNR.MMM2Efglp4uML%7ѷٹP"]Y75:tZ/8
{ߌ9r%o(;(kѰoX
m{qV"@`*(ؙ2>{LbfMHr	2xQ/մzѽD_CvK.D9g\#~h̙3.fZK)Wpkt uR;οzlw	鹇n7Ue
ʎ*_o]|SYp"YiNfi-ަsMm2fY4z 	I͔p]u6CoqqUl lwAU#QKnݶGo*ni3CM;οBLx<@:S3Ρ7R_;NB-RcSO>F,Pdٺ+)7~aJ0?9[7+')kۘXֹ"_F{VFAv
yBey_xEnnaKv#g7|";\%βa'6wxnl0jī(YĹ&
tް>ORLI9^,lEquFd|&-3P/NA*@At~rZH]tL[Tr]zG2~+_JmW/We:pΜ9^J`
ia^gcݰ8,df!j-+j xۣ Eh#SX%z0]|6x}j?=yŁy|#%qwwf27)dy3׶D'wO}Դ 062*=?/_:Mo}ԞL(E.
LUEse/2g?^4
?|*zT9SC_]_J~'SxfͪN@@@LYk@$T0-@`F0
@@@B	
E'g*r@(8Sh   L3B%g*
@@@@ xF   LA39@@@@ P4Hxp!3	    O``|.ÚHXE    NT8@,8S@@@	
g%g*2@88Sl   L"B'g*
R@@@@ XD   f'S8iF#Δs @@@jf*g
Y"@@@`i0@@@p*!$Lcpqt	ޙ/ЮG~olB    0%	vԁNOҙ3럤Gv}QfBfѬYkԇJ@@@L"ytK38Q-ci;TlZ]btt

8@@@ٳgiJuW#$cGDN_Neϑcct`l#eXv;kHUr%ʷe$=3W#SJ0Mpr6xL|@,d'3e)ubJjkQQg;a:qb:`4WGhޣtQ>ؑ+sWoJ;Er J&Q	ѱO)1ԣhz   PsI	8I5͗ZZ9FYݐET]]C7l|hjRcu6XDcǔlٕ\"hW6㎖dfSÆ#td4P
\76\O<@8uԄʙG5]vӾi)}UjrOˮk
Gh_-nN|};;WqnPCv*)N,dr:f]mut5͗iBS
A@@=T|Ӻ^v]E}5Q6X7_98]h͗9jZfvR&ܹs骾SîZ刓$䍒)-đU4;<V]-S>}}}}}`NX)׶z"u&v	mrhXu[陿mؤF]Ƴ3OmFVzsՙaV9ٱ$8vK^Ett?Ӓ8W)OWOpT36"
7I    P~1#S9!@@@*jOX   0LM0pT   PYRL5    P8L@@@1TԹ;Qt%i\&L%F    KT.Ā@bpBF%g*	b@@@@ 18SQ!#31    Ĩ@@@r	eHLTbT   L2A$&g*1*d\%wk8[q(5L]UMԛIRSS/-H62UUU?Sڰ*>ݚk%,]rM飵>^mbi8ҭ󽣫zXqv<jeޫJ62/.	U**lG
Kzͥ#i`SGBWrgFk'CCD#:N#TOΑD<q>qO*;Z\l{hL4N#[< tʮ|MH#dz.!8[2[6bi[
o#ڒI/}mGyɏ?I)KUO"ee
Ove8(ZrgfA=roc4Jo`uF6jYOb2.}[4ukPQK#0#uTL^?@%fijjL-ikw=sֲ#Ŵk€1|O57lU&Xq妏Ů;SF _@-M:_#X_T]<L]T7
i]2CM=UMe*QgΔ:lO:aq]Mî
?}$]34Ktn:|juZNΫdfj
ہ=z
wSUn[)x/{a\tTΓe}As0;n3=*'_0i~ lV__)Gcc<D_ݿ[#i~mesT#ct1F߂rr={L5ɽD̸aHnAN̮K5[{%v|~i;Q㖔QcdSvvw@J-
=}6mh?<˽Zkkk̸>}pW-Uzb9浫q#-<hzr]9}Q(	~7h}d'!\zgi=qVˣ<igگ50uxFԇi\ǏrjZ]O'ʍS7DyU>2|ˉڝ6-{H}
]u
ԍ;2_]3im:ӡ<Fx
tԩX(?;QO/Vea5x quXU>G -.~}բ8zZ268DDw5>f*~jQjyR#<1NPXXH\H_7yaF\h0qmDRkYsHZ߯mBm{i=yO0nIDarawQް{-l p x9̾xu;kƝ\2m9לF.мv׹GMQ>M0o(qaUFV*LvKwrIH,i;57Rntr:
k8^}BP<QV`$C#ME{+?o?&_Fơwh^}\B3tN1OF0u:rUɈBQJcON;u'.fy^t[[yl隽f~3W%.ÖvWm՘y ݼilp1V	k{Zp£c2zƣ˺xuuP(fua}]y%?Z֜k.,e#?l)Թ'l4<r[.ayZf}aΖ_;y\{a-X[R%xJij;n4L'amu~-|2+WOHz0&!דp#LarL@.
nU륜`msCIQΓzg4GƋK(QfBz0g,V#AnaySfwQ=M;	Ӹv)DؘT?fGh~R/TJZgayo:O1?'6[9o0)Nƚ%>[	g(fWk/_yIMg7Yt)1Ú0>ZE	n*p>l)~Lɺ<f<ъǠn@ݴU%`H4FxxvEܰJZzȔC&u~yBsJk"^sz2r<DEtQ7(=y	sٻmFrTwhXSaV"Sh7iߌSex$Ki:BY
Hؾ.b-KdAV\c0
۵l${~嵅09 Od喀KBvFm<wMa62˩AGWq"k}GrҎr#0DP>qX{_0r_8SjgLI:+O嬗
e0WY^:pֹ8ʼnh172#"Z~vZhc/USg4by8ޑ[%ZKBwapz#^`s&N[ZXЅY[VM=>NA10 iXu:iŬ;
lL[_l_Mjb
t^,obtxhaXJqY:E-js͌[Z6ny_*M-	$yL!.,FFזa6s}xfԗsM÷%!QGnz%?G禘,v0yXCGBCɬ<U$SGGGc#sMщ/@j7Tt$NU+T
CGZ.2NI :FcE[X!L)
it1aea<hN	ԬL<îxxH,/@WU-!HW˔6*r   B#S@@@L4̍di!eɣp"*~zN6u&Lݷʋ:y*Ju.M3LDŗeo%S6,Jd
B`b)rtX=
Rۚ');yt3_;;%le%c͏#7-iX6ңl(0-ϔ=YrvAHؙԦ8=ܭg6!:"q:-KKߐR$yum1zUzbKzܵ^^@b@hE+{zZoCK$QnjeD%ǘЛS78,򯁔>@y&fCKw[ַiffRwَm4
ԣV)I\osS7ڬWumj.=OK~ڮ6vH(kkdZ|FƟߘאiMCֻV
q*h#,wӢp,<ݥ>ڴ߱A/KW'G5ӗH6US<Hʓzӑ7n.r8\MkE]jJOA>K&-6tݴZ9gd#OԅcZ(3\ zN6IвYl9e|[lx6lhmٸqYٰp&9m~g(թϺ9iWN=zCIp7ʌ˔MA/˙3)u64+<aFAijE"}.n7y=} @J
U*,9qҒ=Ro>w=rp\&N1zk8(G5qyZMв+k~.M%>0ͭ7N!&|:~ec(3lN
$1fC`\ds7o6Obl\lfXWe]1Y7''#I76˔6lEa:.P2i}&ӎiο)Ykl8,2$ŶxRf>~F^?ʂ6)XXנ6u_S	Td덹ø:Z%	L"Oqmd/"fg6znVo9jt(hi(MAq^1JLb⧑ԛ
pk溹S#?V2^PKщRu(Ơ
NR&[&LDK1o)@2|@iڴX:3?6fC~u"
RV=jHcX!JL/fò6vÐs67G@|Ĝl6.)KݗO
/۰gcsf&AΥl>zBF#-MM9Sl 1o6kHfȆ4ssclJ &K_+|R>Cƒ6g3WM_GQ{El@"yfmXVoۤ\Ⱥ$r:xGM~T؍<eO7'\B6I0bD~sJD_ڞ}_jR=B9-%r6a#].f@-eɴ{1)7_j&i6v\ku77F+3_X<2}a'/mҦ
My!:(>ZNޕZwXo&sl
8ћOGFɱ.x17r!P~<|sҷGTM@`&SŠoN֋)A@ؤ!Ty6    T@@@&@OE@@@&	@@@*kSX   0LM lT   PyLU^"	$gja*#gL 8SUT8Sצ@@@`	HSF@@E0ͧI@@@ g*h(   )M    8Sy@CLi<&gJ'ATP@@@48S>A@@@ V2yE"ёcObgJJx9   Ӂ}g5335>>nHfj<(
L#LWpkn(39@k;]dh˨&LI%^3>בy(93Jn&zd5Gkg͢YҁXt%+@@@@hJ<25FԈtus5ɏ:Mк/8vȯ'M[46   PfϞMO.%%vj.}TV\v.Z1{n+Wl#
hۢ
о9+h7u:8WҢ
GaQz,gwV8-l
G@@@	̙3G'թSJbj閇mDGWТEHrvk/Brd"jfCXɞؑ

ő#@rR	~"@@@*ves_g)Q}A:[\O뮤+WQP"5FVtѪ[0.eŅHPzp,%<)N#Gǎ"7Yuw?uxՉWQDo^w殡p`<up0n<MB99NA@@@0ui[hi5;L_ۭ4^u4[:ha|uGTyUϏ;O,7sLOn"V
cY'L?    P :SK;VoDmlrUmUw줾%Dwٸ{=QߞU4^t9s;j݅ټݡy(9]*jXE{g   U`$0n)L?utt[ڑ   ETe'`p&8,k@@@@$)    @*gsM)A@@@	`ցx&gցx&gցx&gցx&gցx&gցx&Prgj,MMK<&R&hu4/Bb3:#~	jRl}AHNTˎqۯ|ߞ\KKP;Z܍=4k-H#dz\f[*IXJ\-KIDAT8jw+W   %w,uN|T?<Jc^^?@CzXllhjj@z:th=<sF먶t   0	L35JCTUU*KdzӓgCesֶzpjo˕nLez)5gP!-]4VGM$dcR1'ӚaÇu&-4RQƹ΀Z,>A@@`:\g;Ӏݩ8^E];=_G]VRn!j0ղ40S}<]6NC<ôۙR)c¶)[60[vСGhп^ImmƝn=2L1Cj*seryyzIfg#j%0Tc;mlq'ĹC_:LݵȔ1\kVj'Q1SyT׸?fqLؖV%J5p]^805SWAbbwnwNS8bzM+eO"  M`rPBu5s(
-4Zyg˖dfBZHn^]h/Ss<NBKjޔLClW 9N=	!LLɈ
9zbG
zc,vxMW/
O=#t<lW<WeF)5BM[!g͔ҤV,2
Y3UɈmsY4qa0LLY1ީXtz)-Zh)_dYe[厽l1bBN[c!őQ;NcK]Fܩ&:
f+nN'T&*~x#IV)vV|M$_Ԇ @aPLU |L(TU-p2   0AfLP=&-~8OA(o*v   eNT7(opʻ}@3U
@@@ʛnh   PLyA=&gځ98Se@P@@@	*v   eNT7(o
pd	T=E@@@@ 
L󥡅     g*    4@@@L@@@3@@pB^3SHCTZ   V2r8v:::rlNLIo1G"@@@@`:fr!"A@@1ƍA@@
'B4&gj7>L(@i>Y309fߚ<erpnQlu5rmsmԚ;i,R-bQp7>vr„Gt]yΚEf-PN^XK@$}}(93JIzdnqegA;8(K2w`J1]o.j^/fiK}MRrEy,]ܼaaQͷ<L{ͦPkD5⧃RHG`t}RF↿4PC6:Sٱk5s`le<C}ؙ8G9Mҽ?aj)8CQet]“֪zu+Czz=?1n5_y]]
f;X.	'ϔ
aeG1go'].|ھJTΔ||}{׷Pu5zv~Gq>wĉa\ã<<C:Eܿ>&G2{ѣ{Y#{C#+mr@8ߩSGI#Wpyrp1՘f(ץ]yFc褽xN?GⷱG9۰m/r)A~n̩OY@w]
>A@@	̙3g]ܗXI)v
]#ќ9 8gan7-N8	v]IW21~xqGlNTŬeѦ#a軈u*=r,Iґck-r\/{!
ztmH[,$m9jvcvnmEfY
chSVyuz]FQyZj>-N;b^mΔl`j*7'Cч&LXƱE?礓seVEJݴO%ᢋ|4}q弢X{k^GnYL:r"<=,3]5p2Z5x]ڟˮUΕRZZ6_#3
z>:HLu3	$)suG,E^]֐WM]k})usiܹtZ_ežOz}wU'rY}WQR
w?Ӳ-Sѷ/D_:uzW]$l`>>>>>Wpms>Jk4Oaa9x4Mju}\m"YV9]ѕҦKΡM9j;Y,$)u]kU{vҺ'VW8{hѧ6mjK܊VLK衧/[Wo2}؁|h.TKmyj7O{7]B(=l:&KDqW$6=K^5@;$t
7D@R.wCDмGKs3 @@@`#GL5
#~ٳi&@3U҆]BBRp,p&<~W("L&DL?s=w    A|p   qLB:D3I    GT!@8Sp   qLB:D3I    GT!@8Sp   qLB:D3I    GT!@8Sp   qLB:D3I    G`
vQo&p/uS0:|N3[}=UEUUa"Kk"VN"$6CM,T:5ۼ(A1@=ʵw5wy
w޺'](N`ji.ġTB5e(Me8~ZWa>Cc:nFNac#5:!8laRD}-	T0{5ipgeؤ"I\/ck9nV P|L!5멿gG4XN#=~zRokPQ
S{
!±QիKG`B	rQj3ijKmO)OeK2A @`)Vf}?,O'O0]2$SQMU&x..rқxʰWe).gz+CƸLiyNKg)LK}~=;tp7zi4Rt+Һ[iG. բo@cV&fȯH҆rN=>c!r}6E69tXҥ_+NMr*#0pDӵcr!uΐvju[oa!ysd*y31O{}~dk'e_^!@]v{qӲmk^%]opGikkɻQ&:SN"{;7U<UBPGn!c[TXit(0EԸsНrΆ9Nˉ6-^o(GyߝZ)bOug[?۸2G!8Ϩr׻Squ%D殛eLZvi֜頾	ͳ{#cنaPÞb`uM+DfM+7qi0v8we>m#6v|e{eOGk#S7sQkaښc5窚`H+LP928v=I٭yk;}{
_Mf!U$uln{6&=xmDG7Iv\8зϡՈc߉_NQ"3˩.wD@$Q6v(KS}	u#g5|c?D뵃Zw4M=ŹdDhŕĹ#.'G5SvN#A<'V⧘4vv!nfX,e#;RԳ԰z܁J+Tf
-?LЈxS20IF6Ũw&Z@cSmtkEk#Yyq?NJ;ޡ<-BL,a0f{ZDDMV7a)خ5NIiZn06n2K<	#<YFxGܺ[VNT_%0y/vjK-WV/CNjxnlz0]dk;T8Nkd_uF2v{3cg>ؿFPa2ėϙu[l	ǒ6VjXd5~p){͊{XI8eG)M[5NjFFFEzQtFF:xֹfFCZh5Z.SZIk5>G?I:2z+BKw.YWBd<y^diyۡ"?T=ȃS<}%%E}w7(J1Lԩ]q;xL'L5 SQ}f{TׄiE]QDQ&Ϥt{xF<k06=͔ed!?#іvtTadLuT[jځvSZh#ϙJkeNuBRf#Y۵_
:e~&=Qw
RT}
v!T-Yrtf.,R~Ew$7l%.YX~](%S#jNR/k$uJE/@ٟ"d5L'g
3>^o#˝5faY*u7Yodɿ$;)ik3}i1
'ɵwOivo.h_48YG9ɚ	@TtxE#I)/AjC_S<=	:&EpO+)^|2(WU{7‘@pO+2Ph3I*DY^QʚL;*k
\=\ZzL&

3A@@JCTiB*4!gj44(
8S
   ӄi0@@@4L+LpICL3U
   0M&

3A@@JCTiB*4!gj44(
8S
   ӄ@		   T,+r	`/H    @@@L@@@R3@ @
pRBV3$sHAT
X
   ApDp   )$N[ɤ   I#ǮΔs @@@jf*g
Y"@@@`i0@@@p*!$Lcpqt	5SO͜I3khx|>u't/u0~1NKi؝]3\T-S~xfqWAٯnh7B@ەʙ
_s+}:nvrݼ9?snZ|NG@}/U9F:&3zğ~op)_>I_=Cwg
(cK:@kg͢Y[rY|		#e@@@ ?67S'މ8KTMW׵k=rLFd}wQ+%yyr~)tZKpJd*/:_1yjgmй
5%uNۏS3u4%D|D@={6RF
pU}2W}qg]*En~1w3;GL<r|b,}3
/^ky2}+c!fo. u
ֹ/Wŋib&vm+]oPZZ8#p~_ii1w8],z8gE,%O*gRHQiŜ94g"Zs/ڐ@

|vZϗ2rc5B:Eܿ\ɑ
Թ}հm/=zurn
4lFN{G$ZA~"ڰ:nkPup-rDVѹ(º2#Gh{Wgm?t'h{
bs㨤+:i|޽}Lj/m0nwѕ!R(w.֝OL=Ү8A@,9[GL+$\&Δ8YỚ_7.okrXcʝ`fݕtr#t:[XjjXcuTuMu5e\GhÊE*;y؏t>!Ji^9]L5&PvQ
'ӣvRi  eA@P,3UޝӲaT^:vܣ:ܳrc#)22hp^uٚ23uKiTuhyliqv $vyۯbݳuz\l+B1󲎧ktzdpD	`>>>0	~N3]c~AMhFet4\x}s];@zȔTMT(ψ-rzVG--T즯L]EsΥY#:r;kE6m+]of2}(jj:x1ì/k?(@@@@*~O|ZkrBtKNLRn	6]rmLUZF݉-:V!<Mtjڴ.qhXu[FF{=qar^ˆYCC;^[+[:y-sޟ|z%ݻ:G@uOЭn1'oV{_EO-]$qsOii]	  6O7pCx@#	ʩ    PLU@##gjأf
 |`/LTQqBt#ʙ:s   0    MT4@$8Sx   LEA*D3    MT4@$8Sx   LEA*D3    MT4@$8Sx   LEA*D3    MT4@$8Sx ӌ@&3KDuu2TUEU]FezpWUq]Z'584QiAjMt[I{_SWV_[vLmC9@>ϝ"6f+rSUMe\\M	Ude6?ޔ̹nYVɯ0*?Wu	3۳5uQ2x-t_uO3%66R&bipg=-)M0uwׁLiiq8L}'XY&O9jmoRCDTOMĵuttm>?"u"h9Ә\c>P89aarLJ[uM|gUݴӌO٢=d0uPm;
hŰ:ƵZRVrf8l)z]7Yݗ:%;`+bx)!Аǎ^ME42ij)ز{9l-SPեTx<Ў^]S10|ʼ״
e8RyRD5С9bi;DŚj[}FӷnK(,^ɑx}Fp{FhP__SKu#U9S
?$~ZџqpçکUwIc;(3x)Ϛת- 2)y\7>j\Cؗ'L=G.k{j*PM/Ci&wJy5STm2?W0c*+SnV:><9z:L5d-BidetʦOL3~az6=Tmlf՞20FcJ=ODWL?iG'IF9F}qLի]T{ʫg|?չ^|YMm9߬X^#>]N>eka	9#|<#)'G9quejZTM[~[[~{ތo$%[w{/Ϲ?cwS@k@g
רyݘ\[;Jn/FxR)eI,f7WeJ秫18<BmPzSX&a)s9O992pw'0ʬOg#~=LlLyyBtbmtʪ/+"6b.=<0'D~ڡYcI˕߬Qh7"DqsKNEUing^fT_Wsqk0%xdGz:Cn6,|j徱j
V
gF٘b%>n.ntq=爗z]	O|wRF.۾DFklѩxf]7I	M3a2ల'RaX>	ʗT&Sy|C\hE>	?/F5*Or<rZvl&
N"U0=ɒ0Lc\KՎ+Q|"ڸyvAF^dTkFؙoסd85uR@n&^O)SU%7Qg
<l㋏cvزjUf2S&b޿=ZV[ge5 LJep-Lke`nx&|r)o-[F7Cn;%#L(̠RӡFR8el}:1uE|UN{.AvL+R)XBf.K{PLS|Jl,1?Qc%Vϳg"4S-;RG*%TWetV%^BeRݒO]$GM/fWEg5-mڷ6fw\ߵI7ײFE&ؗx<wZ`P$9S7RʠzrV2!^ed(Z/fbva:̕C72-C$|dAON_jԬL;wZeDACZnP=PO5v1ch$PȜ~:$</Q_uG~Xzđצ]+(BNWkxC CAHY2U]ΚV>ے/ysʮ2E#_
wf׭fxd,;٩[t뻺Oz 2-rk]S
|x|}YH'͙RY#\5Y?E/])&:h&ә+ʜ[zZ;p'1JE6|qRWr\<kxİ~1բ5_䴣N'~prT꫺u?TQZhk|\23׀^߯^2UgwM˚oݓ!x嗾#򤑬]>Bf$a.GSx_%<
/z\
uB.ㅍa[1_Yg7Wwk8_I<i;0pfA)عgΞ=S3y8N4w;0>ѳѾu<_}ƨmu%]8enx
*	nk{^j}´eOtU?v_r\zjh\ pG+^	\i0VHFfF6 @TO]} @	 @TO]} @	 @TO]} @	 @TO]} @	 @TO]} @	 @TO]} @Rx H)Z @p/, @ia*M TXh @TL @ "@4 @@SaEHSi2 @B d
 @! L @ - L @B@
- @@Z@J) @0Z @0&S@a*, @ia*M ߋ2/IENDB`
[-- Attachment #3 --]



You have to be careful because in an experiment, I killed swtpm while the VM was running, and nothing happened. Then, when I opened tpm.msc (probably reading tpm), the VM crashed.

So you have to be careful that swtpm doesn't close while the VM is running.

Marco


> Il giorno 28 nov 2025, alle ore 11:18, infoomatic <infoomatic@gmx.at> ha scritto:
> 
> Thanks! Did Windows find and use that TPM? Did you have to configure anything?
> 
> For the CPU problem: at the current state I do not rule out that this is a Windows problem. We see the same excessive CPU usage on our Linux/KVM hypervisors.
> 
> best regards,
> 
> Robert
> 
> 
> On 28.11.25 11:15, Marco Orsatti wrote:
>> Many thanks!
>> It also works in already installed windows 11.
>> I made a small change to the script so that I can run it in a common location for multiple VMs:
>> #!/bin/sh
>> VMNAME="$1"
>> SOCKET="/tmp/.bhyve.tpm.$VMNAME.sock"
>> if [ ! -S "$SOCKET" ]; then
>> nohup swtpm socket --tpmstate backend-uri=file:///vm/$VMNAME/tpm.state <file:///vm/$VMNAME/tpm.state> --server type=unixio,path="$SOCKET" -- tpm2 --flags not-need-init &
>> fi
>> I think it works on Server 2022 and 2025 too, I'll do some testing
>> There's another major problem with Windows 11 and Server 2022/25: excessive host CPU usage. Has anyone found a solution?
>> Marco
>>> Il giorno 27 nov 2025, alle ore 23:57, infoomatic <infoomatic@gmx.at> ha scritto:
>>> 
>>> Hi,
>>> 
>>> I could not get it to work on an already installed windows VM - I am not sure this is a FreeBSD/swtpm issue.
>>> 
>>> On a fresh install I have had no issue.
>>> 
>>> my config:
>>> bhyve_options="-l tpm,swtpm,/tmp/.bhyve.tpm.win11.sock"
>>> prestart="tpm.sh"
>>> 
>>> and with tpm.sh:
>>> #!/bin/sh
>>> 
>>> SOCKET="/tmp/.bhyve.tpm.win11.sock"
>>> 
>>> if [ ! -S "$SOCKET" ]; then
>>> nohup swtpm socket --tpmstate backend-uri=file:///evo/vms/win11/ tpm.state --server type=unixio,path="$SOCKET" --tpm2 --flags not-need- init &
>>> fi
>>> 
>>> hth,
>>> 
>>> Robert
>>> 
>>> 
>>> On 27.11.25 15:30, Andrea Venturoli wrote:
>>>> Hello.
>>>> I'm hitting my head on this, but cannot make it work.
>>>> Is it expected to work or am I just wasting my time?
>>>> FreeBSD 14.3/amd64
>>>> edk2-bhyve-g202308_5
>>>> vm-bhyve-1.6.2_1
>>>>  bye & Thanks
>>>>     av.
>>>> P.S.
>>>> In case someone is interested in the details:
>>>> vmbhyve starts bhyve with:
>>>>> bhyve options: -c 3,sockets=1,cores=3,threads=1 -m 4G -AHPw -l bootrom,/usr/local/share/uefi-firmware/BHYVE_UEFI.fd -l tpm,swtpm,/ var/run/swtpm/tpm -k /zroot/vm/eserver/bhyve.conf -U f753439f- bffa-11e8-b279-a4bf0142162f]
>>>>> bhyve devices: -s 0,hostbridge -s 31,lpc -s 4:0,virtio-blk,/dev/ zvol/ zroot/vm/eserver/disk0,sectorsize=512 -s 5:0,virtio- net,tap0,mac=58:9c:fc:00:11:65
>>>>>  -s 6:0,fbuf,tcp=192.168.XXX.1:25900 -s 7:0,xhci,tablet]
>>>> Windows sees the TPM device but says it cannot be started (code 10) due to a protocol error.
>>>> In bhyve.log I see:
>>>>> /tmp/bhyve.z4HOkg5    873:         OperationRegion(TPP1, SystemMemory, Add(0xfed45000, Arg0), One)
>>>>> Remark   2173 -                                      ^ Creation of named objects within a method is highly inefficient, use globals or method local variables instead (\_S
>>>>> B.TPM.TPFN)
>>>>> 
>>>>> /tmp/bhyve.z4HOkg5    895:       Method(_DSM, 4, Serialized)
>>>>> Warning  3115 -                           ^ Not all control paths return a value (\_SB.TPM._DSM)
>>>>> 
>>>>> /tmp/bhyve.z4HOkg5    895:       Method(_DSM, 4, Serialized)
>>>>> Warning  3107 -                           ^ Reserved method must return a value (Integer/String/Buffer/Package/Reference required for _DSM)
>>>>> 
>>>>> /tmp/bhyve.z4HOkg5    985:         If(LEqual(Arg0, ToUUID("376054ED- CC13-4675-901C-4756D7F2D45D"))) /* UUID */
>>>>> Remark   2184 -                                                            Unknown UUID string ^
>>>>> bhyve: tpm_swtpm_execute_cmd: rsp read failed (bytes read: 4 / 3968): No error: 0
>>>>> bhyve: tpm_crb_mem_handler: cancelling a TPM command is not implemented yet
>>>>> bhyve: tpm_swtpm_execute_cmd: rsp read failed (bytes read: 4 / 3968): No error: 0
>>>>> bhyve: tpm_crb_mem_handler: cancelling a TPM command is not implemented yet
>>>>> bhyve: tpm_swtpm_execute_cmd: rsp read failed (bytes read: 4 / 3968): No error: 0
>>>> In swtpm logs:
>>>>>  Ctrl Cmd: length 12
>>>>>  80 01 00 00 00 0C 00 00 01 44 00 00 Error: Unknown command: 0x80010000
>>>>>  Ctrl Rsp: length 4
>>>>>  00 00 00 0A  Ctrl Cmd: length 22
>>>>>  80 01 00 00 00 16 00 00 01 7A 00 00 00 06 00 00  01 00 00 00 00 2A Error: Unknown command: 0x80010000
>>>>>  Ctrl Rsp: length 4
>>>>>  00 00 00 0A  Ctrl Cmd: length 22
>>>>>  80 01 00 00 00 16 00 00 01 7A 00 00 00 06 00 00  01 00 00 00 00 2A Error: Unknown command: 0x80010000
>>>>>  Ctrl Rsp: length 4
>>>>>  00 00 00 0A
>>>> This looks possibly like:
>>>>> https://github.com/stefanberger/swtpm/issues/1069
>>>> That's for a different platform however and I have no idea how to "port" those info to bhyve.
>>>> I have no previous experiences with swtpm (and I find it hard to get a good howto/tutorial); TPM passthrough works for me (but obviously not on machines without TPM).
>>> 
>>> 
> 


Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?B4F039A5-0C21-4AA9-B76B-B41221BED8BB>