Date: Thu, 23 Sep 2004 16:08:51 -0700 From: Sean McNeil <sean@mcneil.com> To: John-Mark Gurney <gurney_j@resnet.uoregon.edu> Cc: freebsd-current@freebsd.org Subject: Re: re0 device txcsum issue Message-ID: <1095980931.59840.5.camel@server.mcneil.com> In-Reply-To: <20040923225234.GL72089@funkthat.com> References: <1095978035.59583.4.camel@server.mcneil.com> <20040923225234.GL72089@funkthat.com>
next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help
On Thu, 2004-09-23 at 15:52, John-Mark Gurney wrote:
> Sean McNeil wrote this message on Thu, Sep 23, 2004 at 15:20 -0700:
> > Is anyone willing to work with me to help trace down this problem? It
> > has been outstanding for a long time and I would dearly like it fixed.
> > I'm willing to help in any capacity to trace down the culprit.
> >
> > To recap, on the re0 device (possibly others) running -current on an
> > amd64 processor there are times when udp packets get improper checksum
> > calculations with txcsum set for the interface. This causes a deadlock
> > in nfs as the client just contunuously requests this packet and it is
> > rejected because of the checksum being bad.
>
> I have recently been working with the re driver, so I'm somewhat familar
> with the driver. I haven't seen any issues, but I also don't have an
> AMD64 system to test with.
>
> Have you tried to find out if it is packet size related? are you
> trying to use jumbo frames? rwatson committed netsend to the src/tools
> tree that could help this, and I have attached udpcheck.py which is
> a client/server script to test/verify packet sizes of difference
> sizes.
My method of testing has been to just do an "ls -lR" from a large
directory structure. With txcsum set, it consistently locks up. This
is on clients ranging from x86 linux, BSD, a sparc solaris2, and an hppa
HPUX machine. If I turn off txcsum (i.e. ifconfig re0 -txcsum) I have
never had any problems.
I tried your program with txcsum and it just hangs. Without txcsum,
I'm not sure what the output here means, but this is what I got:
[sean@office mahi]$ python ~/Desktop/Downloads/udpcheck.py server 1234
packet send mismatch at: 1792
packet send mismatch at: 1793
packet send mismatch at: 1794
packet send mismatch at: 1795
packet send mismatch at: 1796
packet send mismatch at: 1797
packet send mismatch at: 1798
packet send mismatch at: 1799
packet send mismatch at: 1800
packet send mismatch at: 1801
packet send mismatch at: 1802
packet send mismatch at: 1803
packet send mismatch at: 1804
packet send mismatch at: 1805
packet send mismatch at: 1806
packet send mismatch at: 1807
packet send mismatch at: 1808
packet send mismatch at: 1809
packet send mismatch at: 1810
packet send mismatch at: 1811
packet send mismatch at: 1812
packet send mismatch at: 1813
packet send mismatch at: 1814
packet send mismatch at: 1815
packet send mismatch at: 1816
packet send mismatch at: 1817
packet send mismatch at: 1818
packet send mismatch at: 1819
packet send mismatch at: 1820
packet send mismatch at: 1821
packet send mismatch at: 1822
packet send mismatch at: 1823
packet send mismatch at: 1824
packet send mismatch at: 1825
packet send mismatch at: 1826
packet send mismatch at: 1827
packet send mismatch at: 1828
packet send mismatch at: 1829
packet send mismatch at: 1830
packet send mismatch at: 1831
packet send mismatch at: 1832
packet send mismatch at: 1833
packet send mismatch at: 1834
packet send mismatch at: 1835
packet send mismatch at: 1836
packet send mismatch at: 1837
packet send mismatch at: 1838
packet send mismatch at: 1839
packet send mismatch at: 1840
packet send mismatch at: 1841
packet send mismatch at: 1842
packet send mismatch at: 1843
packet send mismatch at: 1844
packet send mismatch at: 1845
packet send mismatch at: 1846
packet send mismatch at: 1847
packet send mismatch at: 1848
packet send mismatch at: 1849
packet send mismatch at: 1850
packet send mismatch at: 1851
packet send mismatch at: 1852
packet send mismatch at: 1853
packet send mismatch at: 1854
packet send mismatch at: 1855
packet send mismatch at: 1856
packet send mismatch at: 1857
packet send mismatch at: 1858
packet send mismatch at: 1859
packet send mismatch at: 1860
packet send mismatch at: 1861
packet send mismatch at: 1862
packet send mismatch at: 1863
packet send mismatch at: 1864
packet send mismatch at: 1865
packet send mismatch at: 1866
packet send mismatch at: 1867
packet send mismatch at: 1868
packet send mismatch at: 1869
packet send mismatch at: 1870
packet send mismatch at: 1871
packet send mismatch at: 1872
packet send mismatch at: 1873
packet send mismatch at: 1874
packet send mismatch at: 1875
packet send mismatch at: 1876
packet send mismatch at: 1877
packet send mismatch at: 1878
packet send mismatch at: 1879
packet send mismatch at: 1880
packet send mismatch at: 1881
packet send mismatch at: 1882
packet send mismatch at: 1883
packet send mismatch at: 1884
packet send mismatch at: 1885
packet send mismatch at: 1886
packet send mismatch at: 1887
packet send mismatch at: 1888
packet send mismatch at: 1889
packet send mismatch at: 1890
packet send mismatch at: 1891
packet send mismatch at: 1892
packet send mismatch at: 1893
packet send mismatch at: 1894
packet send mismatch at: 1895
packet send mismatch at: 1896
packet send mismatch at: 1897
packet send mismatch at: 1898
packet send mismatch at: 1899
packet send mismatch at: 1900
packet send mismatch at: 1901
packet send mismatch at: 1902
packet send mismatch at: 1903
packet send mismatch at: 1904
packet send mismatch at: 1905
packet send mismatch at: 1906
packet send mismatch at: 1907
packet send mismatch at: 1908
packet send mismatch at: 1909
packet send mismatch at: 1910
packet send mismatch at: 1911
packet send mismatch at: 1912
packet send mismatch at: 1913
packet send mismatch at: 1914
packet send mismatch at: 1915
packet send mismatch at: 1916
packet send mismatch at: 1917
packet send mismatch at: 1918
packet send mismatch at: 1919
packet send mismatch at: 1920
packet send mismatch at: 1921
packet send mismatch at: 1922
packet send mismatch at: 1923
packet send mismatch at: 1924
packet send mismatch at: 1925
packet send mismatch at: 1926
packet send mismatch at: 1927
packet send mismatch at: 1928
packet send mismatch at: 1929
packet send mismatch at: 1930
packet send mismatch at: 1931
packet send mismatch at: 1932
packet send mismatch at: 1933
packet send mismatch at: 1934
packet send mismatch at: 1935
packet send mismatch at: 1936
packet send mismatch at: 1937
packet send mismatch at: 1938
packet send mismatch at: 1939
packet send mismatch at: 1940
packet send mismatch at: 1941
packet send mismatch at: 1942
packet send mismatch at: 1943
packet send mismatch at: 1944
packet send mismatch at: 1945
packet send mismatch at: 1946
packet send mismatch at: 1947
packet send mismatch at: 1948
packet send mismatch at: 1949
packet send mismatch at: 1950
packet send mismatch at: 1951
packet send mismatch at: 1952
packet send mismatch at: 1953
packet send mismatch at: 1954
packet send mismatch at: 1955
packet send mismatch at: 1956
packet send mismatch at: 1957
packet send mismatch at: 1958
packet send mismatch at: 1959
packet send mismatch at: 1960
packet send mismatch at: 1961
packet send mismatch at: 1962
packet send mismatch at: 1963
packet send mismatch at: 1964
packet send mismatch at: 1965
packet send mismatch at: 1966
packet send mismatch at: 1967
packet send mismatch at: 1968
packet send mismatch at: 1969
packet send mismatch at: 1970
packet send mismatch at: 1971
packet send mismatch at: 1972
packet send mismatch at: 1973
packet send mismatch at: 1974
packet send mismatch at: 1975
packet send mismatch at: 1976
packet send mismatch at: 1977
packet send mismatch at: 1978
packet send mismatch at: 1979
packet send mismatch at: 1980
packet send mismatch at: 1981
packet send mismatch at: 1982
packet send mismatch at: 1983
packet send mismatch at: 1984
packet send mismatch at: 1985
packet send mismatch at: 1986
packet send mismatch at: 1987
packet send mismatch at: 1988
packet send mismatch at: 1989
packet send mismatch at: 1990
packet send mismatch at: 1991
packet send mismatch at: 1992
packet send mismatch at: 1993
packet send mismatch at: 1994
packet send mismatch at: 1995
packet send mismatch at: 1996
packet send mismatch at: 1997
packet send mismatch at: 1998
packet send mismatch at: 1999
packet send mismatch at: 2000
packet send mismatch at: 2001
packet send mismatch at: 2002
packet send mismatch at: 2003
packet send mismatch at: 2004
packet send mismatch at: 2005
packet send mismatch at: 2006
packet send mismatch at: 2007
packet send mismatch at: 2008
packet send mismatch at: 2009
packet send mismatch at: 2010
packet send mismatch at: 2011
packet send mismatch at: 2012
packet send mismatch at: 2013
packet send mismatch at: 2014
packet send mismatch at: 2015
packet send mismatch at: 2016
packet send mismatch at: 2017
packet send mismatch at: 2018
packet send mismatch at: 2019
packet send mismatch at: 2020
packet send mismatch at: 2021
packet send mismatch at: 2022
packet send mismatch at: 2023
packet send mismatch at: 2024
packet send mismatch at: 2025
packet send mismatch at: 2026
packet send mismatch at: 2027
packet send mismatch at: 2028
packet send mismatch at: 2029
packet send mismatch at: 2030
packet send mismatch at: 2031
packet send mismatch at: 2032
packet send mismatch at: 2033
packet send mismatch at: 2034
packet send mismatch at: 2035
packet send mismatch at: 2036
packet send mismatch at: 2037
packet send mismatch at: 2038
packet send mismatch at: 2039
packet send mismatch at: 2040
packet send mismatch at: 2041
packet send mismatch at: 2042
packet send mismatch at: 2043
packet send mismatch at: 2044
packet send mismatch at: 2045
packet send mismatch at: 2046
packet send mismatch at: 2047
[('r', 1792), ('r', 1793), ('r', 1794), ('r', 1795), ('r', 1796), ('r',
1797), ('r', 1798), ('r', 1799), ('r', 1800), ('r', 1801), ('r', 1802),
('r', 1803), ('r', 1804), ('r', 1805), ('r', 1806), ('r', 1807), ('r',
1808), ('r', 1809), ('r', 1810), ('r', 1811), ('r', 1812), ('r', 1813),
('r', 1814), ('r', 1815), ('r', 1816), ('r', 1817), ('r', 1818), ('r',
1819), ('r', 1820), ('r', 1821), ('r', 1822), ('r', 1823), ('r', 1824),
('r', 1825), ('r', 1826), ('r', 1827), ('r', 1828), ('r', 1829), ('r',
1830), ('r', 1831), ('r', 1832), ('r', 1833), ('r', 1834), ('r', 1835),
('r', 1836), ('r', 1837), ('r', 1838), ('r', 1839), ('r', 1840), ('r',
1841), ('r', 1842), ('r', 1843), ('r', 1844), ('r', 1845), ('r', 1846),
('r', 1847), ('r', 1848), ('r', 1849), ('r', 1850), ('r', 1851), ('r',
1852), ('r', 1853), ('r', 1854), ('r', 1855), ('r', 1856), ('r', 1857),
('r', 1858), ('r', 1859), ('r', 1860), ('r', 1861), ('r', 1862), ('r',
1863), ('r', 1864), ('r', 1865), ('r', 1866), ('r', 1867), ('r', 1868),
('r', 1869), ('r', 1870), ('r', 1871), ('r', 1872), ('r', 1873), ('r',
1874), ('r', 1875), ('r', 1876), ('r', 1877), ('r', 1878), ('r', 1879),
('r', 1880), ('r', 1881), ('r', 1882), ('r', 1883), ('r', 1884), ('r',
1885), ('r', 1886), ('r', 1887), ('r', 1888), ('r', 1889), ('r', 1890),
('r', 1891), ('r', 1892), ('r', 1893), ('r', 1894), ('r', 1895), ('r',
1896), ('r', 1897), ('r', 1898), ('r', 1899), ('r', 1900), ('r', 1901),
('r', 1902), ('r', 1903), ('r', 1904), ('r', 1905), ('r', 1906), ('r',
1907), ('r', 1908), ('r', 1909), ('r', 1910), ('r', 1911), ('r', 1912),
('r', 1913), ('r', 1914), ('r', 1915), ('r', 1916), ('r', 1917), ('r',
1918), ('r', 1919), ('r', 1920), ('r', 1921), ('r', 1922), ('r', 1923),
('r', 1924), ('r', 1925), ('r', 1926), ('r', 1927), ('r', 1928), ('r',
1929), ('r', 1930), ('r', 1931), ('r', 1932), ('r', 1933), ('r', 1934),
('r', 1935), ('r', 1936), ('r', 1937), ('r', 1938), ('r', 1939), ('r',
1940), ('r', 1941), ('r', 1942), ('r', 1943), ('r', 1944), ('r', 1945),
('r', 1946), ('r', 1947), ('r', 1948), ('r', 1949), ('r', 1950), ('r',
1951), ('r', 1952), ('r', 1953), ('r', 1954), ('r', 1955), ('r', 1956),
('r', 1957), ('r', 1958), ('r', 1959), ('r', 1960), ('r', 1961), ('r',
1962), ('r', 1963), ('r', 1964), ('r', 1965), ('r', 1966), ('r', 1967),
('r', 1968), ('r', 1969), ('r', 1970), ('r', 1971), ('r', 1972), ('r',
1973), ('r', 1974), ('r', 1975), ('r', 1976), ('r', 1977), ('r', 1978),
('r', 1979), ('r', 1980), ('r', 1981), ('r', 1982), ('r', 1983), ('r',
1984), ('r', 1985), ('r', 1986), ('r', 1987), ('r', 1988), ('r', 1989),
('r', 1990), ('r', 1991), ('r', 1992), ('r', 1993), ('r', 1994), ('r',
1995), ('r', 1996), ('r', 1997), ('r', 1998), ('r', 1999), ('r', 2000),
('r', 2001), ('r', 2002), ('r', 2003), ('r', 2004), ('r', 2005), ('r',
2006), ('r', 2007), ('r', 2008), ('r', 2009), ('r', 2010), ('r', 2011),
('r', 2012), ('r', 2013), ('r', 2014), ('r', 2015), ('r', 2016), ('r',
2017), ('r', 2018), ('r', 2019), ('r', 2020), ('r', 2021), ('r', 2022),
('r', 2023), ('r', 2024), ('r', 2025), ('r', 2026), ('r', 2027), ('r',
2028), ('r', 2029), ('r', 2030), ('r', 2031), ('r', 2032), ('r', 2033),
('r', 2034), ('r', 2035), ('r', 2036), ('r', 2037), ('r', 2038), ('r',
2039), ('r', 2040), ('r', 2041), ('r', 2042), ('r', 2043), ('r', 2044),
('r', 2045), ('r', 2046), ('r', 2047)]
Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?1095980931.59840.5.camel>