Skip site navigation (1)Skip section navigation (2)
Date:      Fri, 10 May 2013 00:11:50 +0400
From:      Lev Serebryakov <lev@FreeBSD.org>
To:        Adrian Chadd <adrian@freebsd.org>
Cc:        freebsd-wireless@freebsd.org
Subject:   Re: New hardware, old problem: stuck beacon when here is WiFi traffic
Message-ID:  <1451445733.20130510001150@serebryakov.spb.ru>
In-Reply-To: <CAJ-VmokY%2BS75WiKkgo1sJc=KfjWNqRsX1zm2j=aEQE39wLC2XQ@mail.gmail.com>
References:  <2810538978.20130423164137@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-Vmom4UDoz7EgdnVeQ%2BALuFFXkH9t_Uj7=FwL77S5rKfUD1g@mail.gmail.com> <1813905823.20130423184528@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-VmomhRaKODxis09MjAhUbAUOw%2B6jWBY48JpZR_JgfZZLKcQ@mail.gmail.com> <184105677.20130424002002@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-VmokVmHDXwE7S5koSqtFjPXQ_VUPhj8gfMruDM2k-DyUMPw@mail.gmail.com> <1936997795.20130424003555@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-Vmokx2QhcjcsgA-_kqjX63Vu4CLk7HkuyALautbnzp61ywQ@mail.gmail.com> <886711115.20130424004702@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-VmoksSTBC7jmC-_hvBeJFSD0k28HoZodaWdHm0AF0d1yZJg@mail.gmail.com> <6010292503.20130426001447@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-VmomUsPgHTVGaKHZ_YE%2Bu1ZOjGqrVfh2uYmvOs6gKmhnxOw@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-VmokZBbmHbruKJV-8kvTyOTsiq5_XHnfqUYo3vO68872Q=w@mail.gmail.com> <99510815.20130426122508@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-VmoktRPbnDRbRuwA4i8w50kExs2pwD4yBawL6iOz7F4Bknw@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-VmonCao99MOrm97tQS_f1xS9tieQfg-nQUB4APWVmdJJUBg@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-VmonQXyB_Aik-ApSmgRqT3yhD5Bqrx3zj%2BK M%2BitVmZhY0TQ@mail.gmail.com> <146903383.20130501000714@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-Vmo=n27vAzsEPDwaO%2BjxS-n42WBbiNyfpvmnO931q1CKcDA@mail.gmail.com> <94204652.20130501133220@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-VmonvS_=_vgJufRc-5d4NGfkKtpsUEZh%2BTaE_Th-dEj2W9A@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-Vmo=fFEkRr4-R3g1%2B%2BMq7QoTGD_OFWpHc5jpgbwEcgrOJYQ@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-Vmont9febEE9jOX8ZMp7omMdQ_4wDNRr5gyq8gbpm3x18KQ@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-Vmon0dj%2Bg1ZE28whsvtP%2BshUwoMa-E_XnQu6uFy8cSCUuZg@mail.gmail.com> <94971208.20130503122811@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-VmonPyg6a5ZidA9vZzozVGFc0XHT2MoX3OfhCBrqMxVn7cw@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-VmomOywCicVHP8aLKXhdysad48K7bc-wRudaPYmcuQLcKYA@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-Vmok6fFB=Tb%2BJyGfAGJMLUzJ93LN_v==TJsRv--5bWU8YGg@mail.gmail.com> <105246227.20130509004931@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CAJ-Vmon-3xdX8S15uPCMLpAs52=Tdpk8TKPsajLUpb3yNf49QQ@mail.gmail.com> <CAJ-VmomqUBnFU6wPMbpJbAR9HsvAH5kui66xJH51NUnL3jkQYw@mail.gmail.com> <616955694.20130509234232@serebryakov.spb.ru> <1069622056.20130509234807@serebryakov.spb.ru> <CA J-VmokY%2BS75WiKkgo1sJc=KfjWNqRsX1zm2j=aEQE39wLC2XQ@mail.gmail.com>

index | next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail

[-- Attachment #1 --]
Hello, Adrian.
You wrote 9  2013 ., 23:54:08:

AC> .. now, see how it's kicking you off? The transmit queue is filled
AC> _and_ the station is asleep. We're still trying to send it stupid
AC> amounts of data even though we can't get to the sleeping station.
  At  same  moment, station prints report about received traffic every
  second...  And  there  is no power setting settings on Windows (or I
  don't  know  how  to  find  them,  but  I see big property page with
  different   settings,  like  roaming  aggressiveness  and  preferred
  frequency band).

AC> So:
AC> Try setting  wpa_group_rekey in hostapd.conf to something low, like
AC> say 15 seconds.
  Done!

AC> See if that immediately triggers things to go pear-shaped.
  Almost  immediately, with traffic. Without traffic it seems to work,
  but  how  could I know for sure -- without traffic? :) It looks like
  Windows doesn't update status if here are no traffic on interface!

AC> Then, if it does, try running hostapd in debug mode in the foreground:


AC> # hostapd -d -d /etc/hostapd.conf 2>&1 | tee /tmp/hostapd.log
AC> .. and then watch what goes on with rekeying as it gets booted off.

AC> I bet that it's missing the group rekey notification from the remote
AC> station, and it's being disconnected.

AC> If that's the case - great! We've fixed the hardware bug. You'll be a
AC> perfect test candidate for my power-save queue handling changes, which
AC> look to address this saxact problem.
  Logs for several (3 or 4) dis- and re-associations is attached.

-- 
// Black Lion AKA Lev Serebryakov <lev@FreeBSD.org>
[-- Attachment #2 --]
7zXZִF!X]!{\t@0?mDs^oޜs)
"9rB
@ZO{ FivQ=5HtļL+%	QeyJ>*g3Uss[hzŋCJrAgh	+sɵqoMr2\MWd^vA`_M쩇;<ӯw'/nGi9'?6%n;1!/2x-xbvag^}e?sR4hT0KsN {+/l51IiyVr/۾ļW1q߸=Nl0lj]:.SMQ,ll\{-D63wCcO!5Gm-N"2-5*ޤwue`E`ofB
dD'L_9:"+.aTn®;?SLR	w1
Z8^t>˚.iݶqTD'6e16HLPRŜi+Q^sn<_<c|Uҽdm
HÈZ{tmi.CpjXtIux^(W*mY75:y?ˍ.o=IS93fK[$HiJ_~BDSre6qLJy|\9K<H:8{ӥZט·bs䩬l\NmnA>khBns u}$XZRFZKy3*a?M[IN7tbk0
ZۓU=^:ONuR=Ԃݼ$Ar6J$>&7axNa`Xv2q.~쬧~L$I3Тeɺ%BT*A!os`6Ϡ]$/{{eC:ֶ8{KΫ,ϥg~wpݵ%+5<T:G`My4
}Isi_	lэoS&fmy/",~Դ[^CoGq571)"gg:䐦ף|>pPɝCArdЉ .QH'Da﹙-\f
WR}n3M>rn<ee%V0DV7?_­}7@ato]Q}m0TϹ(hnLU+@
l4_v[ARpw˙A
^Yd/re#i᏿R'lg%+RG:BKC"r5OPN%ɥ~TDn?L^Mh"r/LCw]RViHש"cC,_1j{L\'Qη)]51k A=)XU:p{U6IS1?,r$6vOϮS,١b}b6=J1Xg˓	'΁ʿ@潭jS+KR3aHJ<SGZ^ /{dx4p]r3prhcneVF-R07J1
j7F0*uHJC|[發"Pqjh>I[| T ytYoj-2 ZDy?]Y	BU99dd)ޔA%6K@ (*b)eyl_f=XcE_0=e¦R.uMyѮ1GyֶS
MuKH6|Y޸Wmqs(`ofչw@XN!BN",v_xx~BA иu:Ed3wu$JSpNbpmC:_/Q>p3	6R{ﱣ;ۻ9*FAyjӌZ̋xBbNbSP
ݖ,

E1>*zϕ  Atʼڵ*9 ̨gYIѩ/[G򍛪͜2pFV|.*-I^ײf>K~)ZUlj+[4;a
Z:wc`>\-E@'{YB9{
6+q4fb#F;Dv:lM}GL&E] sord2!VWk#݄Vb ҵhmVjO>{UM>$j-7W7QMHb.j YXUi9-usORk^h81Vo#Qt++4 -gVnvC@G>+m?r!(evm%"[|NO\^S$GOJFO@yn	hN2ԓ
m/ybtټEzw!5tit|K<n@J_52v=Jz.翐u0&{14}|fY0+!GX,h:hC>VPCԁ?iU1pGɥfmq|ٮо(;M؎
R
J
<;0"$?9܏Flg;'o3+yq
T	3nهj}Xa[)ԼSTpLɜ/#ys$bO״l2( =!mmIkGYr+9Cu)3Bb[?X+sOۃȂ띺4>'.ZА<B47MӘ
On{+Vpr3QvKO7}J;t/8.5`fXoagYZ
[-- Attachment #3 --]
7zXZִF!X]&K"M-Eć^Jx?0t[/e92Bx0:N
xpﭮaI_\G	)CqDIpx_ݩm(wv0/~>o=)5Z%GR徐K\/K}$:ͦ3{FjgQ	Eiq6w:s<Zm+"C?LڷxhĭH๡QD	
zLR	mܤ)Ovs5P͢L^@κKS<6
@ -kDIk ~q}<ֱ{xsvt*wsᤵr6|;4_Xđ=,ΖvȑXjL,R4|خ6>cENk,-><\0܊|9G͗v-Z?h:׾>ha¶(NBff;\+Eil#,ґtү\Q/8	Db ?j*8x56"Q3xw;6.h\6^U_1gn	L:zfb4`;UGHvʧHk7]"-\F'$[V-Cܰ=PCVF
̥[ۤG!Eujq5LȸPgVܾKY`׹_;~!J`lއd`i#*zbp5š9ϭ$+ÅڶښlWuM<Y@$>ocoiP8NnԴf"17M2ЄY΀滿ׁԻoFLphB$s$b,zτ+ F-1E137^kZԎ`# [SXX}=C>!GQgR#ʖVQ6,`\5#˾Xy;S|_N0pWK#5Bpގ|Z;Fj׹=pfYi\
+
V(fQytXC_kq}yuZ*‹	ׅ_EϷz92tVz .2^ Jg.fs[‹׿Ll
-'{~Ov-h՛y<qMjn($:s!򓳉vL	AƆcԨUVԏR	ȕ+er2Z"@2PAJh(*cq*#+fH3$m[Kson¶0n6)$v'xVJoCKl5╬&iàgpdy@۝ȻCԖq-eS[2q\z#V.E7xm}r
\RZ)mPz߮&ɞnGJqLIJN)koC$63i	dނoJr)tTJ9^jE(5}(&[b{ݲЩ_裗!	[ht)OIĻH5J5GdjmR
UQ]{~3{VuvflxX<o#OQ}`ռ:f@$zUP9DLѳ^5JooԹ|gsu>8e.s5qX;.A
٭A@5ň1[,saL#*;)c~Q@1*Tn:"J!=\ÿ?Mm|
%Ul@d[CaM/~MGnsbj18fmXwtixX`iTyhX5ߟw1	}uV	Q=$+dbzK 8~l5fzWmDJqB϶e@/ߖIq̘#28=ymr)5.}*=aQh̀q_
$HR5lye
hح'dD]bԠ7P>rYJ!"ZQ0i+;|2J>I2o+xP{xbBR`m$22cH\RS)<>'>>
#8Q2HV-m 
YrHɺD
&Aցb+|dC%l>r;Awg.g4il&sf=k^&dS@ӖYX=,_]ُXVxEvHyk;κ#b_;q$' =%u+V ᥎<!^g?C%'/)CAg\b\."MVޫ02Zjdžs)1"\?JAZoq1%«;[gN)S
O!(A 38s_:끚f1A๳y-x#k}`ӠۨfңIe-0-ڿ/uI_REcFC-2ӑ+@w<KۣVP42Ɏ'<MVBRRd
;Z§ce-4	{RLa{S9],K"8M`b4;O/Gqo"f@_MXߙ	x&!AmuUcx{:m'^dAgRxͣYG0f돉#2FŖ:Ÿ,ﴷ>gGdbr'c	_ZR׵<	h#`<œF
/6z#gO"}X˦e\^dz|b)eL,-w[pz
$]oSJLW3j%Gi2$o8	ja91NvQZ	xFu@p	H7ɼ/>[Z(@@!UiivX/GO_b{~belLHzK<䱂7_0>_\iV%_CĒ5lcljY7?ŔBnB?Й#ٞ$E{w8j~^iXC5\/U8AܙK4y>[VΣZv<P%w:㥙
E9|fzG4y_P347=/inZ6~&ԽrY/[UFSgu&<Ր<ZXWO3X|E%)rwꧠx̀c<B?z|ً`s
rGQm1{tcZo3<U5_wjF?)s@i@(q)hh3YFyp'7JU$|B`
a7e}v1@
}8I6_i
Bр$}!2ٗ~Q湈yq~D*
j^ڿ5F&m\R~QǙ;<)ω@lT{IfrZu&7}oeSB	7%)4>$+'8<㽜z)Z3}0-92sR-L
sm+L~uy`dvhk E\
>J-jV\|wv,.Ƨ-٪miq&
㚁'r@? .d#øWC	<3+A9F#%#Lp@x~XizL&j^WF;"Zq}X\8
oRf刽V0N~4"҂_!$
4p]a*cPsۯ-H_׼| "b$c!?KޣG2a@PUnϰ e!*Ћd$x(-@ԢHH90Gr#qTz*j-@`nSW
XEIwG]42P8),gbֺW
*iFhgְqu١tmnUP`p;|pez(qu|_u%bH><]D{Ke %ZtǪI(Ki@I#L8ރbQ_?|o)k{6TC 햩[7"O>iSJQl5Ir}QnJH)C$@5\59O<pmX^
SAe1d^%F/eqAC#>FdDwt)/Pp.]פTfƾ
CE{C?nlIC;*7'u\wLBK^PӘ
+#vۺ|G~%h&GYe68|"ASAv$V]h( K*ͧ&)e
ex

kTTC9YGx<,,^twG&usīܿ='zQM}+8-H(+QOԲLoY$@<5'8cE(G/mAo"uӁ;ވa,37]‡IK
pw$D\㫡Â]LZf)F֍k$t48O  n.49^+3[3F#$t
SLS~lJZcb'/ǝ!5Zԓhbc#3՟D_Im`%"cU"LC%MU({*JQNn,Y(CDg	Nt`1*uMls.kkרZܵNcPPP7Pи1'rll'7z\BGam;ůfJ~R絧Ejdȋ_r?*ĽFӰG<()%3-R@jm 8;s
&",%'w	3D'‰܄;¥f4/"W1duM=
d1{LQ)&j]]'_RjVύQהn4r8شaĺ5)e\+k	 3g3\#G*g_$\V&ΜR!dJr#gCzdedqL|9316Z+օ,[Л&bL/Y\4TnrRh#fY|h- F21uZ4	_O:TpM2h3;@OwIb[3kFOe\7IJovV<5xU»T]<D/dǽՆZ͡_s	
dn4afWX)]Қz6?̓-n|ؙBD(Vz[
v-
I'<#><.r|Av!%c"EWtH}im2{ ZVE\)\xf8,=JE=Lú#Gs
S)D%)
VxV@ޞewIks)9R)UDj?D1SJF-68*ݷ}cE-j0e^>\L46NP3//lXS'$d Nͨz,	8XtMMXXK|]*]4f-=ҙւ2prjG\Ip
]h|,`9Tm?:C:qWqhɟdz2{TUUK&X&=1$#JhE'SY0KBX=
M
Kvz<p9VH<Ta?Ř;LKka'wI?`ǰ*[k5f~b)2nl=m	 ^M/k;VU<b,y$4b0@[:SX^Xu;^)E[R
=Qtƈrd0ĦS`⣿i44"iK1C=bA<hX[03	%F×tNj4b|_`o@Ӿ=7&+ƦUR+ݼ_#eSz
((-~0)
пOc2
윇1V-FDI	YiIRmHofcz&ڒ
}ؼ)99rʑ@~(/?jGW0*cI`C;y(w-N?[߻]ub4$R8啙>U6{
+'G
єWJ<ph'V}@8֤GtS@GskNT3So]
ľ#b"<Ed+9ogc~ljzaIBQ/{𽗯2t\8N1NBHPWqa!]Ef#Űq(bTK~<0UW>vH9э玅mIl9R!MhKjD[[PgɌelWWtX,*{t:w}FU}+.Ѣ[D|`Zp[jeo!,gE*'
.Ze>V~.;;/T؍;zXߧă.j(|VN9,̦HtjGH@B^GV'x܍mF&{]
-W>}t%E!@+3x>/"w|}݁=f<%N	$N\˵[暁7kZkwBI8/_A?dNBswdHL gCW >˩.+ԗ@a0N;E[ !UMDK:^]d;9aF{`Oy^T-s\Lt[r~lJ;^zhdeT]kBrhb:Q
.ƒfAрeLI;U~(ac:췧9Q09džDՍAB蟪:e<
>u潀A.,'	tlR9ij ER{~*^Y;sngTTv秇:0)9PWCXa/zcB=*dxّ	~+Ǝs<g{7Fe)A ꊂ.:?zDgYZ
help

Want to link to this message? Use this
URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?1451445733.20130510001150>