Skip site navigation (1)Skip section navigation (2)
Date:      Tue, 24 Jun 2014 19:36:41 +0200
From:      Hilko Meyer <hilko.meyer@gmx.de>
To:        John Baldwin <jhb@freebsd.org>
Cc:        freebsd-acpi@freebsd.org, freebsd-stable@freebsd.org
Subject:   Re: powerd stopped working after update from 8.4 to 9.2
Message-ID:  <6hcjq9540905oeibsjnf8ogee7sqfcdoej@4ax.com>
In-Reply-To: <201406241026.52678.jhb@freebsd.org>
References:  <p8seq959o50elg2p5t3po3ouddnfb20p50@mail.arcor.de> <201406231609.53123.jhb@freebsd.org> <1mchq919q3su1ji3sgaamjugv2jdu5bbgs@mail.arcor.de> <201406241026.52678.jhb@freebsd.org>

next in thread | previous in thread | raw e-mail | index | archive | help

[-- Attachment #1 --]
On Tue, 24 Jun 2014 10:26:52 -0400, you wrote:
>On Monday, June 23, 2014 7:12:23 pm Hilko Meyer wrote:
>> John Baldwin wrote:
>> >On Sunday, June 22, 2014 9:27:08 pm Hilko Meyer wrote:
>> >> 
>> >> powerd doesn't work anymore after the update from 8.4 to 9.2. The system
>> >> has an old (more than 10 years) mainboard with Via KT133 chipset.
>> >> 
>> >> I made a verbose boot with both, 8.4 and 9.2:
>> >> 8.4: http://pastebin.com/iiZXRXgK
>> >> 9.2: http://pastebin.com/sHcd3MHv
>> >> The relevant part of the diff seem to be these parts:
>> >> 
>> >>  viapropm0: SMBus I/O base at 0x5000
>> >>  viapropm0: SMBus I/O base at 0x5000
>> >>  viapropm0: <VIA VT82C686A Power Management Unit> port 0x5000-0x500f at
>> >> device 7.4 on pci0
>> >> -viapropm0: SMBus revision code 0x40
>> >> -smbus0: <System Management Bus> on viapropm0
>> >> -smb0: <SMBus generic I/O> on smbus0
>> >> +viapropm0: could not allocate bus space
>> >> +device_attach: viapropm0 attach returned 6
>> >> []
>> >>  acpi_throttle0: <ACPI CPU Throttling> on cpu0
>> >> -acpi_throttle0: P_CNT from P_BLK 0x4010
>> >> +acpi_throttle0: failed to attach P_CNT
>> >> +device_attach: acpi_throttle0 attach returned 6
>> >> 
>> >> Any ideas what I can do?
>> >
>> >acpi_timer0 also failed to probe due to a resource issue. Can you get the 
>> >output of 'devinfo -rv' and 'devinfo -u' from the both kernels?
>> 
>> Yes, no problem.
>> devinfo -rv:
>> 8.4: http://pastebin.com/6xm1tBrU
>> 9.2: http://pastebin.com/whXk32Ab
>> 
>> devinfo -u:
>> 8.4: http://pastebin.com/47U7HZb3
>> 9.2: http://pastebin.com/U85HTw0C
>> 
>> thanks for your help,
>> Hilko
>
>Can you provide your acpidump?  This box seems confusing.

Well, its quite old. An Epox 8kta3 from around 2002. I was not sure which output
you need so I attached acpidump -d and acpidump -dt.

regards,
Hilko

[-- Attachment #2 --]
Sacpidump-d=isȶ+Tn1Z oB08sk\656M^*"[-lj<z;[s^>/3[e:=zςJ*^d3]cPt>S45TϞ?\LVʇI
cxM?qq<y޾<=5߮]וKP5@EG9BoſQ	1D	;3zwA? ܪfMƹQSv*P]t0Z]͕>˗g*~&,_b}[Qa)'/ynW Ȇ[Cqq/Pϛkߧѐ{!кKt5J!VKLwn:":~z|_PW@}X=A=jݯw3$7a
 `1|AQG
YS~
?^}X>O?aE#9żRd:=OƟQ51}qu\O>r^*&r9B9.e$t)bƥ"5uԋOP<1@4/n{
Ќd)=VSi5CuO=j860`u‚H͖ѕ
T 5aG_wkm|RSx|X{(c
1ŠNoD2'ũ?PU,1FSo
ʷ&[ͤ|;O<@P<@P<FCQ(xh<4
FC+v׍ϥ^zCiGC(,)||@'kqB0'jV~WuS'T3lkDPj_y헻;}@R9"Vp]?Lnk','IU	B3
~D(
!9[}kԠ=دT'ۮơz92޶2mь+&J^2i\cN8iD	
ˬWy%bR/2ЬێVX_Jơj^6mk3(Υgg!
1v:I:m#a[g4]rz>dbJY0m`[&Kb/GI␐jr

Pioa7%kS24`)	*@R#eP&DcQв"(EYŎGbWkӠIf"87zoWEѓ{Okv׳y1Q]h"?1`g$b)H#)hh]cFQ?j)AFmпk)yjDFN@FPeт=xrd}a
	N]AQhh>Z=.QYjPІvB(A!4NU
Db!п	ߨ%iwm}7^rRelpU6bzga;nut$!,'GRbt^#O厞V&]/R2b2EQUK.a]m5-'aLa%
ߧ͑a9^فϝ.@U}Bl$od/#!.med|0a~~㱄a,&(xz~!d="H׼-lb
2:QK=^hIoK7V*a<zX؇(Ub^8jyX՟w,1`d0P%$Q$4>NqLA(M)p?CVMez݀artK؍tm争F@uA#ӍƐ&FF
@Y9|[-Ɠ\qAoMd$2'$,wnp@caF*ɾ}SꞸUtN$
Vcͅ4abD#AX;"^zai&^ab3qJB(рEr"E	r-UOú3eRH'oA系}zۚ0a#k@2DFV+[fI6XѩNR0ReclVƗm41N&&b:tU]qXytsZïxIú0MV<ͅKy5a CZey
eh-_E]Mg,.l̗N0f.V[Bb1<gަ>@@M^=x#1ezb(u]Xbwh4hrim{fqqgrqz?C)c^CҰP	2"T$eJF|St`LRmuHAE ו_Q&/G_wPţO6D!#ƻSBZ')C$t32{ؙOp7df~ 3n@/j=P7ey숅)cA
ڍP|IeҘcx(P4-"Jŗj{99JRU-Ճ.4:8jpԩ8ztlװw@{|r/t67/WI(<F_$yQ>¹IGi4{.{^
,b
vSnȎmcTM"

,N8>^5_9 %x.?%ˏ~*AX%ˏ~];?8vi G,?O}>qowN\;'N+_JW''_N<:8q'.]7Pp_FfSdRUM:m	SZvI\NfC>/ lC.7POaKF\8 6:;:CNȴoGM)`Z5Uo'&\z]r):_N=X+QӰ
@yp/唱|#Ŋ,X)w]o?c0@#WD`^x,+VbM+UZ-
z\A]+ш$痦LlP61_\t1Ve@y[laȸ.{%̋Qx__GByPꏶ-Tn4J	h|xt-n6ŖY3?.Ƨ-U=ȐQ~&Uvtl|hskrkcS΁i/|e-IB՝,EW3[HUlSՐmljT59F&m?OND
$ӳ18 W
	{ZrMTv`7r2ޙ.U\xn/ddO
T6IvfWwga{n
2H7H\`H:ͨՇ999JY5P'T4W
g^7곣cb&ؙ]U"d9"ҊdƊK$[["E]˪JB'P!$P*JWLD$U1HJb=ĕS	@fOr+Rȝ@@I+R@xYgD~Q󊼘^HOT7dᑻ:[/&HO_XPso\K%;/nw|q_%_v;/nwlwXzB}DHapP7'UzlB>fPO'ڿƜbop߽iE
`#6i6b6Ogo	xhk,E'm}\΁0LUePzw(/NMmQI
wEpׇufd	UԄj-Olń~l
iiԸ~e0z.dOL"ImH2f3CaJҪ7^M8$4=3T@0TP?!N6.	3ƣ㻽QE"(q$L
SX
&ФQ?#9s:\.v[X,Yi<Z5 PUzZT:T*}?&{_ɥM<ߝl	p=)lVGMC JCP{[>#Fqy^cy^(&sL٪1rVl_&'4ՔgMۘW?7
LyY0a:	coΤmWch2@,mӅUY$H*
mPpucŊ1Sur(,b{w҈|FFeNJ4̆F1E˚7a"P9fN}cGhπVPFP(QWPQf#	*dW%	֐@H>g
Op츎&eo&_ٛ7koao27q@7`
(^d{̲Xz.m,j9	 8=EL<ԽB7e}Yvk;uڳX=~},k~O֕)DЍWS8uŝ.Hˁjy?_g3;\Ûxu1Kx[~n\¾؛e 	WW^CL0OϏxI3C=x+d5t+x<ΰ׍zެ@PZu`XKnTK[ի?o'oA]Yj3.cɭl\]&mMW4j9ˤ?LVjkou  eKjugoܭf6k|>s,+hxy6'R>
G
T)޳r\ձa!%MӂZcTY#a0XlzsrN0L\"6,+/楷wk;сKBK߇nF/ڿNI#{~ts^k/\{_dj}{	mVە+o[mxmmV۪,sqQ͍L7bcYߋ\:ۯu:a\g{?]g;:k|: Wմ:W>Rpۅnxnm8vۮnp;;ҍ]oCq*/}^tPX9Kv;	/Y{Kw@"S}Sy镗~^Kw
{xN1/ҝ^SymC0’^:>
G⽱nМu,H!zÉ7,9Dz:w	x!*A1{AUF-xB-/(Ҋk`Qc0LhֹrЕ|xv(lTGVcPO|)ޫ*a7ݯ=JI$nC"'aHxDO$5 Iv"5d8'RKf0Ls A$vI?,dIGHn~"tﱂ?$ԷX2DNHϗsq|
K]p
o1]!?=Wo'z{/W.Xt/㷤2ż)C$DpeVoduaH}I;^)8wǐqKnْE-pTntd%!ƩHYT:<hʄ=?ɭ`Of{lUA_Wp"J!A^WGɾ_:_tkM^]MB:#
C&2Xl.9ģ4eSqtN)kpʚ䔝s,NYSfsN)e9{M4w9&/#y^vMh#'XEϱFEzٽ،Dp`
!Dfyz"]
ϫfn4o2E)Abo[k7$x4*k3:@.Oṙ'6j`38c^)>4B/ cmv`Z߄8uNdג#!(xBE,Mr*#J<R֤I"LB@ECLͽ'iHx8\0
c敒NoRvs4wy3T?;fm>9GGbObYנ g8\SAl!qNHUP3Pց>aqϛnP=>/hԥ[G
=AxPgܫٱ$gkA1NVZF Due
oj/TA,ZyMZU
bb*]ĐL0yY,rbִ3tQকb}c^ߴ>u.*.?+ZF&RˡV.ל7r[-D&UR1R*$gNE/%k0 =xr`vU7Jo@o6<|j,oc[:oeyռ	nc^yB=wsۧpO;zk(5uޢڎZ/!L4,~kj>d혧%%ߐ]~r4*-ei*Dםʢ{ɪ4VRRRf/
IR܂@THUhTS(/*ݟ[R*ŬR)!M*ER)U*JT!*R*RRT\*URJ1\*E+;bC*3LȓJ
	RYƋfnv]/^9Q	@wЎ0
;JN:n	8r

3b5m`+
{x7:SI
W*_㫠^e`|U0
W*_`:ot=t+ :k/E4aJ!^M<O`p_&.@~J]H!RyK8%Ҭ.E%_$"Jzp)#9:_Ւ]ƷN2mpDЂ-ɴ	f#k&YMbNUVVׅK2JJ4@XR>'ÉI<%i۹=Mm*S"K7⠙|r$#Iz	ړ^o`m}\ڛm^m[r޲;![TmCb$^KzkycOt4Z%^A<h
ŵj0C
{KgBL,[`g7y	;+B=7|qkEZuPͳ[xKzϳ%K։\4ɰByaN1#pϖ)ȇZM_$I
n8IIkl觕_H?|
/_)62Lk'dLZѤ4gT5/(P7cktʞߴ^}fD6	XPX+2`kXҭo+QyZ+ז-ʽ2*g`Sx7;G90fz'WCS8#~%8'u=1YAIPb,)φ=|ԶGu	Sl0PǑHY	`, +>PQe"kSdz7x@aB*"ߒ4e#WN:gŝ5J5m\+s:ȁG	WE͐"v:wĻ蜒ԉXy'Ilh`fؖ<h>Ⱥ',!{gmzKR6J-NkD2dd4l/;+"DZƣ6Oߓ㞕c̓
"8+R{`"H"j^!CIL2"l*9-L_۷bN"
[-- Attachment #3 --]
0Sacpidump-dt=nȲW~MRэF`A#ӎ0+9
RfsfdlV[WUW3II}s[_jUI7h}.[r(www,Ui|&/Wk`gAU2y֨ch/i8Gf`uMQeSln,jkZL_R&K7p5/T10'vo8Migow-鎜nཿ-nF{v#k"dg[~vO
Wkh`}"uܡ>FFoy8ju>eO?/5ewѰ;شjVr,y]!-ۨ󹣌::DFU	Q/s~@p6goQ߶]k7ms=ԿΠ(tVox=ؠ;ƨG0vj>UkYu;Za-~_o|C_wz@Ч_oٛJ }Fgo>{"LQ@CKsT39@nx׵T?l=`|V|yJz#x!4;ATRdSUP=cs1N*ß?1_<l6wһӻizt1\sUϞ?p8M)_`>s:?o_@9G<9	kabXu-fX%2\HIUgVA*R]_p}=W"LD" ت0IV/kߧH~cžtc@F(
3ӻΦ85?>W}T%(b_g$#gPg[.ùq H]o_o{ua3;ŠZtxyUJ'=
H}'u-ye?v9J#jb#{i!\y>f2iaOuϕO&U7G*l]AHR3,ѭ/n0x{/~eM-0HVA@>cץ|wZMVSՌԻV}T>:`f(,	B oJ2[v6HRł
+ߴ+:m|RSx|X{ mƷ㻆O鷢kIEq;}o
JQ(o
ʷ&e(x
(x
(x(<

BCPP(x(<
*/_[wNx.uշ9fB 9^b:~wwa3LߺN~2tCJniONΰ}7u| 꾽uM<8Fֵ
)zV}"J=•GƄa"Qන6{DXE
aM.٭#@o-\~Ū<ANv43_ͱ`htif\I5aUjt۽q53.:&<Rӿ[z+,v%4ZĤ^
tɾY-~(\Qz۴-`d=!5Bce
M"a[{4$]rZz.dbLY0mY-u@TwI@K%1a%8$,
cR7%m8ĤcmJ_b
D5_eEX4JrEDєBiP$3XOƃn+
mU=jQԨSݮ
uFk+TWOD=rnH"4bk#טjU-97؇~1Vi;!§6LZ@\@ARTE6ёsd> xU	^VQ|b{]#Ԧ̡
l&QBh
\C9	@	_Diw7vtR%lpU6bzZ͠vE7ή::붣Sƕ	k$˃XDhDr,&U;(!bݛϟ4xoa1ŵےrBcAIlBCsdbWmr܆;=G6d<q67y22ku37=X[Οo=>=@WGzWh*ʓbMRϻw(/=~[%Y@fWT
B;JX4Z,a
B1/8,>G0y0sHR@I\X;	LBaؔbd/Ժtvstn]c`7e<ݨh|F@&&O75r~gOVpUE$B6=u/ W6[uU0IT0foH7ul[EH@NX%3a\VFXEJ6*	5ª	f&ʚqªVFX5t(

X{M\H/'.Q *Y*ٯ?ZF)1	f}0J1M[քcI !Z2KAƊNuZhøY4z1+E`kq4q4k
%wmk_|;}4>f,s!B¢nvEhȐz^AĠ#(ZGoQ?&ju\\-Ƴ1\`Lt0{#m$6<@/T%VKv@Bu.
`7}PʘװIi)*`g1}ߘJl5]xӣdnRib,UisWp/>QL'_JH#ƻSBM(%$Nf"5OHG<5Gx;>Z_;Ak2mVy~숅ǂڇKʤ1- 䛇{xB<(_˭m^lt*IX"ӻpK⨑fѣ(er㓖lnZ}
A~1_Dya>¹Ii4{.{^
rpjsb$)@$Ƕ1M"

;:}\`Do/¯oucG=v ]~G=v*@
#q8qo7N\'/K_։?։qƉ'jxp.(*k8f]dܐeM:m	SZv>%{N&C!G]'ٰN#.\8".
%=Г:햑\g`	2Qq(`ZըUmEN"\&r):/cs,~5H(WqX5<~X=~9ez%1@%3)Vʭ n7))%D_ &DmZ$XW6ˊX~$ӊzRIk@PW
4"ެGm]Op6}61-t0ǖ0̿Lͷ; qW]HJR	v74!J-[lbYmjtV(`Q^4"+|q#./+Nyvɟzun1zmwJ9ȡej63*mIs+'Nu^"ثܭJr*6mljd59F&vm?ONDv_N48 U
гE]kǍ̄wpefu!/vNB{'}V a%oNkrؿ?)swsr$	H\a:Mԇ888JpY5P'T4Wg^7ꓣcb&ؙ]U"d9"ҊdŠKvjN޷DT`O*BIHU@H&b\0;&Wz+*Ğ|	@*#K*;^} ZK*s^dz $9,y1
nHv+6:&wGt	^`ǓrX > _vxK"^*ψ螜q+nw\qWv-v;q+nw\qfDtDiw8R#sv'@
Tr?ɍ -Mc*$B7S
nooZi*Ak25$#†̆3>AOm9dl
ACi*>ষ8T+V剭sM2B>-
֯DFMEd	H IlqfQA@=La;|Zuǫ7"MPw8H 4TKLx7SP%mC	4i3lT`AF?4FOѪ%=N*o~/P_RLXʦCUN6TL]+!!.^;X?~1</ȯ&sLD٪1pVl_&j'4kgM?2LyY0~:/	coΤmWch@,mUY$H*
mPpucŲ1S۱r(,bkw҈|FeNMJ4̆1E˚7`P9zJ}mGhπFPF
P(QPQf#	*T88K!ֳ|N*4.q/-bo7nio^q_q7n޸eoހ@7x{x1
F2R`q^YJJŤ&,$2;[ӓ@P
ݔyGN*:7F?g{tY5~7Hwk5MhUɚ.mHsȆlW]ěܡ"%<݉boy]/\Rso9&\m]-1yx=>=M$:Ow*י*qUUkzQr*P@Zw RGf-HneL7q2}A]Yl3.cɍQ7B [ UdW?lyzJ
m2ߦwjkou  eKjduo#"Hǻ[-[l|2XV|,"lFgOhe7}r"Ȩc:`gR7cBTiK9D#Q-Fͷbe#{fYϑLVF80q]XFڰڱKG.	K/}^t}^:['hG\wқZ{͵TV߷f]ۻ4֏ֳۺg.N2ܸt+:;vսe{_]gP3Y[u6:_u6"v/׮RXM0s.#u4669܆mdp.fts^m(fK7_n`ʀxt3⥛k/]_{&H_`jͽoC1K/ҏK7xff/</楛"^K7K/m(	F8mC1Szxo4g$'6RHp`pw|9(Lg.O3T%Ⱦ?<TunDPҍ'r-%ۮvE>d~z{,]yNgԝΦϏ$57Xϐ)SvǜDRDb7!IrxD2OzI@dD!RDjH<ӭq&`]Db7!IϣWbݬ<~:$A$NcnN;{g9łg(^<DOHO0_^8pC.Lzkƫ?Ӈ'z{/Wޢ*
[4y_'=,y<<W0HqIR;n)8wG_\۳%Z03:h䑎FNE:Yu>fWzS'?`<5li;bi@;i.o(Bj˴}uu{\#hhlnBi5i
e-vɡ1 e^8e
Li)kpʚKN)kqN)8e6l&Ξ`ճo<Gdyج_X=ը%CF6
9QlнbvG6FtT_gBHx цIoƦbWGʉMLp
IU;ڌ+Bjs!eG-xSxnFem
z,N؇]ȱ5P3k;HX43ok:'yG<xp	-ʩ+HYF*BswΜ=E <5O5T{&5Ka̼BRɩUn3>N? tkv3_F|铜r4\ߩ{$$t
"qE?lT
Փ
l1'uZS|9bvA]u+iq&/ϽM=l/1Q]j28K(eVE{AF*XكX!1f0H1f0+b4tᦕb}c^ߴҺu=J՟)?c}̧\ˡF*ל7rCβPD&UR1R9W/lUdID<k^ResUKa@({bezO,{֛;iw	_ki>oU^-ocj坷V9oubV$3
qR{2˝2:uk@%DWvWh|x+u4^m7	Hdd};iEG7d_>4ѐ{ɪ4RRҥRR^gfB"+2P<UDR:UafJKJagJiJQ&2RRʐlJ)mJ)S)e*%_*QRJiTRt*y z^#M*л7rh/+HJw0^mkD,eyH	?5h\aYaJI-GN[a&P>mAx[4^X9\`|/ePe0Ɨ2_`|/e0~8C[vnC|Dg
⥈&)#2$yڭ	4$H.@R\`_P"/Eʙ"zp)#9:_Ȼodᴉ9&<uZdH$'6	9UI_[P-_Nd%s9S鞖#$n4ƫ2%0z3^S&Is$I/8_zUZBjy[;W9oV[TmCb$^VzkycOt_[^A<h
25hT!&-cmRIil]BhBvSqR^:A>n}Ղl%`D		g.jdY0A8T}gKoC&IO?$IXB6SϧRچ~EЯ|kIt/FprLZLZѤ4gd9-(P7ckxʞߴ^}fDnBWE ־DU&*_WV(/-[ze0e:z^_,Zhiדe>'2	9zݮs

'oM|6ۏ-cXܟИ<:3u> *9o-{IvGFK4VLފ,+zl"Wf`u"q$~}\1buwր*s״s-G@#y<rp匯dO{Q	+-qL):
<=$	
RdgےmYdsb1s#_\LKlRfMVIC$$dk~IՄ3IRq&3;')/%=+5ƚeDd3p
/EE|EռbMԇKUZ6dDخlul'[J4o


Want to link to this message? Use this URL: <https://mail-archive.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?6hcjq9540905oeibsjnf8ogee7sqfcdoej>